Grassroots TV ads for Iowa - It's on

Lots of arguing in this thread... I read through most of it, but could someone please inform a newcomer to this thread what has been accomplished so far?

heheh, first let me just say that we, at RPFs, argue about EVERYTHING!!!!!! It's par for the course around here. It's our individual spirit. But, yeah, it's gets old after a concensus has been formulated and some want to beat a dead horse.

Anyhow, we're looking into pricing, and working on a script right now. Then we'll decide, as a group, what networks and programs we think will target the appropriate market, and after we've hammered out a script, we'll put visual to it, present it, and start funding for it. Not necessarily in that order.
 
heheh, first let me just say that we, at RPFs, argue about EVERYTHING!!!!!! It's par for the course around here. It's our individual spirit. But, yeah, it's gets old after a concensus has been formulated and some want to beat a dead horse.

Anyhow, we're looking into pricing, and working on a script right now. Then we'll decide, as a group, what networks and programs we think will target the appropriate market, and after we've hammered out a script, we'll put visual to it, present it, and start funding for it. Not necessarily in that order.

Very well put! You certainly have to be a bit thick skinned if you want to flourish in these forums but it is well worth it!!!
 
parocks, check your pm :mad:

Thread split, check the vent. This thread is for planning and coordination, not for arguing efficacy
 
Last edited:
@parocks the ad will be made and will be beautiful. You can choose whether to support airing it or not.
 
@parocks the ad will be made and will be beautiful. You can choose whether to support airing it or not.

Very excited Adam!

How long do you think it will take until the video is made? Also, have you decided which type of commercial your wanting to make?
 
1x60 second to start and likely 4x15 secs soon after. The 15secs will all be the same style as the 60sec with the same voice & similar visuals, will bookend the same but the middles will be different where we will cover different issues. They will be in the style as the Reagan ad in post 1 but with updated modern visuals we will shoot. That's the thinking at the moment anyway.

Hoping to have some ready the week leading up to Ames.
 
Last edited:
I haven't been criticizing the work you do. But instead of the same 1000 words over and over again, i'll shorten to "what does the campaign want". I can look at it, think it's good, but since I don't know what the campaign wants, I can't judge. I'm expecting something good, beautiful even, and I think that will happen.

@parocks the ad will be made and will be beautiful. You can choose whether to support airing it or not.
 
Hello everyone, I'm currently under my fiance's screen name. In the future I will posting as ron paul nyc liberty HQ (can't post yet due to pending approval) so keep an eye out for me under that account name over the weekend. I was directed to this thread by RonPaulHawaii from NYC liberty HQ.

I might be the guy everyone's looking for. I'm a media planner here in NYC at one of the major agencies. I've done plans for major and local advertisers (Hershey's, Legg Mason, local Casinos.. to name a few.) I have advertising data available and tons of research at my finger tips. I would love to put together a plan for this or provide direction where I can.

First off I would not recommend contacting any media companies yet, as they will eat you alive and inflate the rates because they know you are most likely unfamiliar/uneducated in media. Make/create a temporary agency, or contact a local agency in Iowa(or anywhere) and work out a deal. I say this because, if you buy through an agency (or say you are a media buying agency, create one etc.) you receive a 15% commission, or discount, however you want to look at it. These media buying agencies will/should cut you in on most of the commission. My current client receives 12% of the commission in the form of a discount as well as takes advantage of the negotiation skills we provide. Second, pricing is crucial, with the right money you can leverage your buy and negotiate the rates. If any of this is confusing, I'll be happy to elaborate and answer any questions. So, before you get into pricing etc, I would suggest taking this media planning process in steps.

First understand and define the target audience. Since the current focus is winning a republican primary, the target is republicans voters. Based on research I've collected, 70% of primary republican voters in the last elections were 50+ years of age. So I feel it's safe to say, to make an major impact, the target audience for this effort should be adults 50+ (I'll call this A50+).

Next, understand where the A50+ consume their TV (broadcast, cable, etc.). I need to do some research for Iowa tomorrow but I can say based on my media knowledge that this campaign should focus it's efforts on cable TV. Cable will give you the most bang for you buck. I haven't looked at the cost per rating point in Iowa but in Miami one of my current clients is currently paying around $650 per rating point (for prime access and prime time) for Broadcast compared to around $175 per rating point for cable TV (on average). That's a huge difference when reaching the same audience. Also, generally older audiences subscribe to cable more than younger. Once again I'll need to pull some research, but I will be able to provide which cable channels will provide the biggest impact on the A50+ target.

Sorry for the long winded post. Again, let me know if I can be of assistance. Let me know if there are questions. I'll post more research over the weekend. If I can express anything, find a way take advantage of the 15% commission/discount somehow, negotiate the rates, and advertise on the most effect and efficient channels (bang for your buck). I highly suggest cable TV. Hope I can help facilitate this.

Also, it depends on your message, but I would recommend nothing longer than a 30 second commercial. Research shows viewing audiences generally lose interest very quickly and you will also get the most bang for you buck for 30s. Longer commercials are also worn out faster (ex. by the 3rd or 4th time they've seen it, they hate the commercial, so it can have a negative impact, esp for long winded messages) The TV stations will also try to convince you 60s are a better approach. I really recommend against it.

Edit: Bookends are also neat. This is when the first of a message begins at the beginning of a commercial pod, right after the break begins and the rest of the ad continues at the end of the pod.

Also, sorry for any grammatical/spelling errors. It's pretty late and I'm exhausted.

Hello, I wanted to pop in again. I'm the professional media planner that wrote the quote above. I'm now under my new screen name.

I've pulled up some media research for Iowa. Looks like the Adults 50 years of age and older audience (which makes up 70% of the republican primary voters) are not very TV heavy users. They spend most of their time listening to the radio or reading newspapers. This does not necessarily mean TV is not the route to go, it just means they listen to the radio and read newspapers more. TV is usually always a strong medium in most markets. I really stand by what I say above, if you go the TV route, I highly suggest doing cable. The top cable channels that Adults 50+ watch in Iowa according to my research(MRI) are (in order of rank): Fox News, AMC, HGTV, Hallmark Ch., History, CNN, Discovery, TMC, MSNBC, Food Network, FSN, A&E, Animal Planet, and Lifetime.

To recap my first message above, Take advantage of the 15% commission/discount somehow, try to negotiate the rates , go with cable if you do TV ads, wouldn't recommend ads longer than :30s, and most of all, I would suggest to act very fast as the other candidates are in the market now buying up everything. There is generally a two week window that I wouldn't recommend buying in. If you buy in that two week window you will play a very high premium sometimes. Prices are already going to be high because supply is limited and demand is high (ie the sooner you buy the more money you will save).

Project leads: PM me for more research/advice/suggestions. I am happy to help in any way. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
good. But we should be able to harness the creativity and talents here, for projects, generally. I think a planning forum with a screening factor might be a good thing.
 
This photo needs to be in the tv ad! Its perfect for the brand.

also, I buy about 80k a month of television advertising for my business.. if you want any help.

r
 
Last edited:
This photo needs to be in the tv ad! Its perfect for the brand.

also, I buy about 80k a month of television advertising for my business.. if you want any help.

r

Honestly, I think that picture makes him look like an 'old hick', stereotypically. Just my different reaction.
 
Which, if you think about it, just might appeal to Iowans.....

Not if he appears retired. What I meant is not that it makes him look rural, but that it makes him look disengaged. Retired.

Whatever. He's terrific, I just think there are a ton of better images.
 
Back
Top