Why Kamala’s Price Controls Will Lead To Shortages

Brian4Liberty

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
Messages
63,479
Why Kamala’s Price Controls Will Lead To Shortages

Why Kamala’s Price Controls Will Lead To Shortages



Politicians very rarely blame their own policies for the suffering that they create. They usually double-and-triple-down on their bad policies. When that doesn’t work, they create an entirely new policy to combat the bad effects of the older one. Government “price controls” have a never-ending failure rate throughout economic history. They create shortages! But when politicians are faced with the choice of either blaming themselves, or creating shortages…they usually opt to create shortages.
 
More original ideas from Kamala Harris...

Executive Order 11615 of August 15, 1971

Providing for Stabilization of Prices, Rents, Wages, and Salaries


Whereas, in order to stabilize the economy, reduce inflation, and minimize unemployment, it is necessary to stabilize prices, rents, wages, and salaries; and

Whereas, the present balance of payments situation makes it especially urgent to stabilize prices, rents, wages, and salaries in order to improve our competitive position in world trade and to protect the purchasing power of the dollar:

Now, Therefore, by virtue of the authority vested in me by the Constitution and statutes of the United States, including the Economic Stabilization Act of 1970 (P.L. 91-379, 84 Stat. 799), as amended, it is hereby ordered as follows:


Section 1. 
(a)   Prices, rents, wages, and salaries shall be stabilized for a period of 90 days from the date hereof at levels not greater than the highest of those pertaining to a substantial volume of actual transactions by each individual, business, firm or other entity of any kind during the 30-day period ending August 14, 1971, for like or similar commodities or services. If no transactions occurred in that period, the ceiling will be the highest price, rent, salary or wage in the nearest preceding 30-day period in which transactions did occur. No person shall charge, assess, or receive, directly or indirectly in any transaction prices or rents in any form higher than those permitted hereunder, and no person shall, directly or indirectly, pay or agree to pay in any transaction wages or salaries in any form, or to use any means to obtain payment of wages and salaries in any form, higher than those permitted hereunder, whether by retroactive increase or otherwise.
(b)   Each person engaged in the business of selling or providing commodities or services shall maintain available for public inspection a record of the highest prices or rents charged for such or similar commodities or services during the 30-day period ending August 14, 1971.
(c)   The provision of section 1 and 2 hereof shall not apply to the prices charged for raw agricultural products.

Sec. 2. 
(a)   There is hereby established the Cost of Living Council which shall act as an agency of the United States and which is hereinafter referred to as the Council.
(b)   The Council shall be composed of the following members: The Secretary of the Treasury, the Secretary of Agriculture, the Secretary of Commerce, the Secretary of Labor, the Director of the Office of Management and Budget, the Chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers, the Director of the Office of Emergency Preparedness, and the Special Assistant to the President for Consumer Affairs. The Secretary of the Treasury shall serve as Chairman of the Council and the Chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers shall serve as Vice Chairman. The Chairman of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System shall serve as adviser to the Council.
(c)   Under the direction of the Chairman of the Council a Special Assistant to the President shall serve as Executive Director of the Council, and the Executive Director is authorized to appoint such personnel as may be necessary to assist the Council in the performance of its functions.

Sec. 3. 
(a)   Except as otherwise provided herein, there are hereby delegated to the Council all of the powers conferred on the President by the Economic Stabilization Act of 1970.
(b)   The Council shall develop and recommend to the President additional policies, mechanisms, and procedures to maintain economic growth without inflationary increases in prices, rents, wages, and salaries after the expiration of the 90-day period specified in Section 1 of the Order.
(c)   The Council shall consult with representatives of agriculture, industry, labor and the public concerning the development of policies, mechanisms and procedures to maintain economic growth without inflationary increases in prices, rents, wages, and salaries.
(d)   In all of its actions the Council will be guided by the need to maintain consistency of price and wage policies with fiscal, monetary, international and other economic policies of the United States.
(e)   The Council shall inform the public, agriculture, industry, and labor concerning the need for controlling inflation and shall encourage and promote voluntary action to that end.

Sec. 4. 
(a)   The Council, in carrying out the provisions of this Order, may (i) prescribe definitions for any terms used herein, (ii) make exceptions or grant exemptions, (iii) issue regulations and orders, and (iv) take such other actions as it determines to be necessary and appropriate to carry out the purposes of this Order.
(b)   The Council may redelegate to any agency, instrumentality or official of the United States any authority under this Order, and may, in administering this Order, utilize the services of any other agencies, Federal or State, as may be available and appropriate.
(c)   On request of the Chairman of the Council, each Executive department or agency is authorized and directed, consistent with law, to furnish the Council with available information which the Council may require in the performance of its functions.
(d)   All Executive departments and agencies shall furnish such necessary assistance as may be authorized by section 214 of the Act of May 3, 1945 (59 Stat. 134; 31 U.S.C. 691).

Sec. 5. 
The Council may require the maintenance of appropriate records or other evidence which are necessary in carrying out the provisions of this Order, and may require any person to maintain and produce for examination such records or other evidence, in such form as it shall require, concerning prices, rents, wages, and salaries and all related matters. The Council may make such exemptions from any requirement otherwise imposed as are consistent with the purposes of this Order. Any type of record or evidence required under regulations issued under this Order shall be retained for such period as the Council may prescribe.


Sec. 6. 
The expenses of the Council shall be paid from such funds of the Treasury Department as may be available therefor.


Sec. 7. 
(a)   Whoever willfully violates this Order or any order or regulation issued under authority of this Order shall be fined not more than $5,000 for each such violation.
(b)   The Council shall in its discretion request the Department of Justice to bring actions for injunctions authorized under Section 205 of the Economic Stabilization Act of 1970 whenever it appears to the Council that any person has engaged, is engaged, or is about to engage in any acts or practices constituting a violation of any regulation or order issued pursuant to this Order.

Richard Nixon
The White House,
August 15, 1971.
...
https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Executive_Order_11615
 
https://x.com/XVanFleet/status/1825224661132890617

I grew up in Mao's planned economy, where the govt not only controlled prices but also rationed supplies. Everything was rationed, from food, to cloth for clothing (no ready-to-wear clothes) to toothpaste. Whatever wasn’t rationed was always in short supply.

One summer my mother used my share of the cloth coupon and bought enough cloth to make two tops and shorts for me. At the end of the summer, someone asked me why I never changed clothes. I then realized that was because I wore the two identical sets for the whole time.

Occasionally, the free market would make a brief appearance. In certain parts of my city, peasants would sell fresh vegetables that always looked far better than anything in govt stores. I’ll never forget the day I was trying to buy some vegetables when the "market police" suddenly showed up. People fled in all directions, leaving scattered vegetables all over the ground. It was illegal for peasants to sell and for consumers to buy.

This is the future that Commie-la wants to "forward" us toward!

Comrade Van Fleet is clearly in urgent need of becoming unburdened by what has been.
 
Andy Beshear was on "Face The Nation" this morning trying to explain that this wasn't "price fixing" (transcript here)

MARGARET BRENNAN: So it sounds like you're just talking about antitrust policy, but, which is something JD Vance actually supports, but Republicans, as you know, are accusing Harris of advocating for price controls, like in communist countries, where the government sets a price rather than the marketplace. You just said it's not price control. But can you explain, then, how you define what an excessive price is if you don't have a benchmark?

GOV. ANDY BESHEAR: Well, first, these are types of statutes that exist in state law. The Texas Attorney General has prosecuted price gouging violations, and I don't think anyone is going to claim that he is into price fixing, and neither is the Vice President. This has to be evidence based. Ultimately, you bring an action and you have to prove it in court, so you have to have the evidence that this is beyond supply and demand, that this is people taking advantage of us. Certainly, we've seen it after natural disasters and red states and blue states. It's just making sure that coming out of the pandemic, or in difficult times, that people aren't increasing the price of food just to make a bigger profit. All it is is making sure that capitalism stays within the guardrails. And it's not new. We've been doing this in the states for a long time.

If they exist in state law, then why do we need them at the federal level? Has ol' Andy boy been able to stem inflation in Kentucky by using them? Or is Kammy proposing federal statutes that are more stringent than what you find at the state level (in which case his statement that they already exist in state law really isn't a very good comparison, is it?).
 
Andy Beshear was on "Face The Nation" this morning trying to explain that this wasn't "price fixing" (transcript here)

If they exist in state law, then why do we need them at the federal level? Has ol' Andy boy been able to stem inflation in Kentucky by using them? Or is Kammy proposing federal statutes that are more stringent than what you find at the state level (in which case his statement that they already exist in state law really isn't a very good comparison, is it?).

Didn't you know comrade? Nothing works until it is implemented at the global level...
 
x-profit-margins-grocers.jpg
 
The High Cost of Kamala's Price Controls
https://odysee.com/@mises:1/the-high-cost-of-kamala's-price-controls:1
{Mises Media | 22 August 2024}

Ryan McMaken and economist Jonathan Newman look at what happens when governments try to control prices. It turns out bad things happen.

“Krugman: Harris Hasn’t Proposed Price Controls and It’s Good That She Did” by Jonathan Newman: https://Mises.org/RR_200_A
“Kamala Wants Price Controls, and It’s Not Because She Has 'Good Intentions'” by Ryan McMaken: https://Mises.org/RR_200_B

 
Back
Top