bottom line, women our individuals, who want individual things.... Acala sounds like hes the closest i have heard when it comes to understanding the majority of women i have known in my life (myself included) although not on everything...
i didn't read through the whole thread, and not at all before i posted my above comment...
but that being said heres a nutshell of what i think the majority of women want
when i say we, im only speaking for the majority of women i have known, and for myself... i am not intending to be collectivist here:
we want to be respected first and foremost... this included a broad spectrum of things, including but not limited to, HONESTY, communication, etc...
we want men to be somewhat dominant, but still hold our opinions in high regard, meaning, take charge, but ask us what we think first (this one can be tricky

)
we want a certain amount of "southern manners" ie.. be a gentleman, not just to us, but other women as well (if we see you treating your mom or other women with respect, we know its likely you will treat us this way too)
we want to know you will protect our feelings when necessary
we want to know you will defend, and protect us when necessary
we want to know you believe in us, and our independence
we want you to be open minded
we want you to baby us once in a while to an extent, but don't let us take advantage of you... this should be a two way street, no one person doing everything for the other person
we don't want you to put up with a bunch of BS. Show some self respect and tell us to "knock it off" demand our respect, but again respect us the same.(do unto others...)
we don't want you to let us take advantage of you
we dont want clingy, neediness, desperation, egotistical, disrespectful
do everything you can not to yell at us, remind us not to yell at you as well... yelling should not be tolerated in a relationship... mistakes are made, especially if yelling is a habit, there should be boundaries set, and a reminder each time not to yell
don't be afraid to apologize, and expect an apology when its due as well
try not to be too pessimistic
be nice

(not just to us, but others as well)
take some time out to focus on us... especially if you are involved in lots of extra-curricular activities... include us when possible, and let us know your there even when your busy
theres probably more im forgetting but i think that should help some of you out
i think this probably goes both ways too... girls can follow this advice toward men as well... i have the most amazing boyfriend, who not only "gets it" but gets me as well... i think thats important in a relationship... one of the things i value the most about mine, is my boyfriend understands me, and even when he doesn't he isn't afraid to admit that, and he still treats me with respect after almost 4 years, even when things get rough... he lets me know frequently how much he cares about me, and i try to do the same for him.