Damn, I thought I've seen pathetic before, but the_british_are_coming takes the cake for reckless and incessant mudslinging without contributing anything of substance to the conversation.
That said, I really hope Kade is right and Gunny is entirely overprepared for what's actually going to happen...otherwise, I'm entirely unprepared. Sure, I'm expecting hard times. I'm anticipating eventual economic collapse, food shortages and extremely high prices, and for a time, the store shelves might even be empty...but complete post-societal apocalypse? That's a scary thought (although perhaps more welcoming than the nightmarishly oppressive scenario I'm imagining). It's very likely that the bankrupt federal government will become increasingly socialistic and tyrannical, even to the point of putting all food on a ration system. The control grid has been set out (and it's being tightened with Real ID, etc.), and living "off the grid" is eventually going to be nigh impossible...we may end up facing a lose/lose choice of living under an overt police state and martial law in the middle of a long economic depression or making an almost certainly suicidal stand against it (judging by the complacency of most Americans). I'm just not seeing any lawless scenario under which overbearing government simply collapses and fades into nonexistence. Governments have a way of perpetuating their existence, and if the federal government falls, it will simply be replaced by an even worse NAU government.
I do agree that desperate bands of looters can easily become an issue, but...the way I see it, there are two choices:
- "Bugging in" seems to be the docile and passive life of a person blending in with the "I Love Big Brother" crowd in order to remain a part of society and ride out the storm. Sure, you can purify your water and try to protect your stores of food with guns and ammo, but the first time you try that, you'll probably be taken in by the "proper authorities" for owning illegal firearms...so the best shot you have is probably to make it seem like you're as hungry as everyone else. Then again, you can "bug in" Waco or Ruby Ridge style too, but...
- "Bugging out" seems to be the life of a fugitive on the run, especially considering the guns you need for hunting will probably become very, very illegal soon (once again leaving you with the choice of making a suicidal stand or not once you're "caught").
Neither choice is particularly appealing, but I'm not seeing many alternatives in the event that all peaceful and political liberty-saving measures fail. Am I completely off base here? Keep in mind, I'm probably the worst person in the whole world at survivalism. Although I'm sharp and a critical thinker, I'm the same video-game-playing, sheltered couch potato that survivalists make fun of.

I've only fired a gun once in my life, I'm scared to death of chemicals and explosives (including firecrackers, since I'm adamant about keeping all of my fingers), I have no first aid knowledge, no farming/gardening knowledge, and to top it all off (giving away my age and overall inexperience for the first time ever on the forum

), I'm a recent college graduate still living at home with my parents. In some ways, that may be for the best - uncertain economic/financial/political times are probably not the best ones for moving out and starting a lifetime of rent or mortgage payments and debt. It's wise to minimize expenses. On the other hand, that definitely limits the freedom I have to, say, learn how to handle firearms (let alone deal with arcane "black magic" like reloading). Hell, I don't even know where to begin, muchless begin without arousing suspicion of being a nutcase.
So I guess my question is, once again - am I completely off base here? What kind of scenario are you guys (particularly Gunny) actually envisioning that necessitates all of these measures without making them almost futile (particularly with respect to guns)?