Article 1 Section 8: "Rule of Naturalization"

[Phillipi27]

There is a particular clause which states Congress has the authority to: establish an uniform Rule of Naturalization, and uniform Laws on the subject of Bankruptcies throughout the United States. My question is this, what is the rule of Naturalization? And what is the point of having one law on bankruptcy? Is it so no state has an advantage in creating a business environment? Do we have truly uniform laws on bankruptcy today?

Any responses or comments from anyone that knows something about the subject are appreciated.

 

[Exiled_LFOD]

Dear Padawn,

The first question I suggest you consider reconciling is:

What is the difference between a Rule and a Law?

Clearly there is a distinction because both terms are right there in the Constitution in the same sentence no less. I will suggest an answer:

A rule implies no police power whereas a law implies police power. Laws of bankruptcy may require enforcement whereas a rule does not. A rule is more like registering to vote. If you meet the requirements you show up and provide the evidence you meet the "rule". No enforcement or police power involved.

Sincerely,
Anonymous Jedi Master

 

[mrsat_98]

There is a particular clause which states Congress has the authority to: establish an uniform Rule of Naturalization, and uniform Laws on the subject of Bankruptcies throughout the United States. My question is this, what is the rule of Naturalization? And what is the point of having one law on bankruptcy? Is it so no state has an advantage in creating a business environment? Do we have truly uniform laws on bankruptcy today?

Any responses or comments from anyone that knows something about the subject are appreciated.

Naturally we are all considered bankrupt.

 

[Phillipi27]

So basically natural law dictates if we become bankrupt and do not pay our debts we should somehow be discharged and in this particular clause Congress has the right to create a law that fits or perpetuates this natural law.