Why did they not use photoshop for a "photo op" over NYC?

JoshLowry

Señor Manuel
Staff member
Joined
May 10, 2007
Messages
11,277
Take this picture:

xbbqer.jpg


Edit it into this picture:

29qo6qq.jpg


And you get this picture:

1e9c2v.jpg


Did the government do this to distract everyone? What from? Swine flu, torture, something else?

This "photo op" could have easily been done with a lot less panic and fear.

I think there was a reason behind it.


Welcome to all the freedom-loving Americans visiting today! Our members have built a great place here - feel free to wander around and see what you think. We hope you'll stay a while and check back often and maybe join the discussion - it's a lot of fun!

Always love your country, but never trust your government.
 
Take this picture:

xbbqer.jpg


Edit it into this picture:

29qo6qq.jpg


And you get this picture:

1e9c2v.jpg


Did the government do this to distract everyone? What from? Swine flu, torture, something else?

This "photo op" could have easily been done with a lot less panic and fear.

I think there was a reason behind it.




.

Yes, yes and yes.
 
LOL this is exactly what my mom and I were talking about on the phone earlier!!!!!!!! she begged me to make that pic... thanks for doing it... mind if i share it with her? and is it okay to repost since you have the LF (TM) on it?
 
When you have technology to do something, and you do it the hard way, usually there's a reason.
 
More than likely they shot video and the person who ordered it was too stupid to know that you can "photoshop" video as well. That would be perfectly inline with the ineptness that exists in government.

Or... I can put on my tinfoil hat and say.. maybe it's the same Air Force One that they used in Mexico and they needed to dump the waste tanks since somebody got sick during the return flight from Mexico and they were afraid of dumping the infected stuff over Washington. heh.
 
No-one can be THAT inept. So let's take a look at the tinfoil explanation.

Obviously they did it because they needed a REAL reaction, as you do with most psy-ops.

The main reaction was to cause panic in New York, possibly to build on the fear of the swine flu outbreak there. Swine flu is the big media story at the moment, which has made people forget about torture memos and government corruption.

The only other wider reaction they could have expected would be to cause outrage nationwide at such a crass and irresponsible move.

Air Force One buzzing Ground Zero? Not going to impress anyone, especially when the cost of the flight went public.

That would create a media event to draw people's attention away from something else, and have both "sides" of the media and the House arguing away on national TV. Also to subconsciously drag people Bush-style back to the memory of a large scale terrorist attack.

And nice Photoshop work, phill4paul :)

Edit: this was re-capitalisation of fear. Never waste a good crisis - and a crisis like 9/11 can keep on giving, even years later...first anger and rage, then terror of further attacks, and then after the dust settles a bit, you can re-awaken those fears with a similar event; especially when your city is playing host to a possible pandemic outbreak.
 
Last edited:
I have every reason to believe that this was an intentional attempt to scare people. I just don't know why yet. It could be covering something else up, it could be testing to see what kind of reaction they got, I really don't know.
 
Because .mil pictures are HUGE resolution for printing purposes?

It would be just as easy to take separate high-res photos of the city and the plane and then splice then together, as Josh so beautifully did.
 
About Half a million dollars for photo ops and widespread panic was worth it?

Obama and his handlers need to speak up. They lectured AIG executives on spending, what about their own wasting taxpyaers money in these tough economic times?
 
I agree, but there are some things you just can't fake. :/

I can appreciate the spirit of that photo...but I disagree that there are things you can't fake. For example...

Damen.jpg

...this is not a photo.

This digital painting of a Chicago scene was unveiled at Photoshop World in Miami on March 22, 2006. It is a panorama of the Damen Station on the Blue Line of the Chicago Transit Authority.

Adobe Illustrator was used for generating the majority of the basic shapes as well as all the buildings in the Chicago skyline. The rest was created in Photoshop.

• The image size is 40 inches by 120 inches.

• The flattened file weighs in at 1.7 Gigabytes.

• It took eleven months (close to 2,000 hours) to create.

• The painting is comprised of close to fifty individual Photoshop files.

• Taking a cumulative total of all the files, the overall image contains over 15,000 layers.

• Over 500 alpha channels were used for various effects.

• Over 250,000 paths make up the multitude of shapes throughout the scene.

The realism is astounding, even minute close-up details.

Damen1.jpg

The front face of the train was created in its own file. The reflections in the windows were added once the train was placed in position within the overall image.

The side of the train car was created in a separate file. Duplicating that file made it easy to add additional cars.

The duplicates required changing the reflections in the windows, the accumulated grime and the car numbers to make each car appear different.

Every symbols, every piece of text and every logo you can see in this picture was created in Adobe Illustrator.

Damen2.jpg

The grime was created with Spatter brushes, available within the Photoshop brushes palette, which were modified to randomize the effect.

The rust was created with the same Spatter brushes but with Color Dynamics applied. The rust was in a separate layer that was also given a layer style of Inner Shadow to add the dimensional effect of the rust appearing under peeled paint.

Damen3.jpg

For comparison, here's the real thing.

damen-milwaukee11.jpg

This kind of artistry really makes you question what is real, and what is not.
 
Last edited:
Take this picture:
...

And you get this picture:

1e9c2v.jpg


Did the government do this to distract everyone? What from? Swine flu, torture, something else?

This "photo op" could have easily been done with a lot less panic and fear.

I think there was a reason behind it.




.


LOL please understand no criticism behind it or intended - you tossed it together in just a few minutes only to demonstrate, and I know that

But the first time I saw the composite, my eyes tried to tear out the roots - the sun is dead opposite. :D

You'd have to chop all the text and vertical mirror the jet and replace/adjust the text, and it would work perfectly. Best thing would be to spend the hours and hours you DIDN'T have to find two images with the sun in the same place.

too much time spent in Photoshop...
 
I can appreciate the spirit of that photo...but I disagree that there are things you can't fake. For example...

Damen.jpg

...this is not a photo.

This digital painting of a Chicago scene was unveiled at Photoshop World in Miami on March 22, 2006. It is a panorama of the Damen Station on the Blue Line of the Chicago Transit Authority.

Adobe Illustrator was used for generating the majority of the basic shapes as well as all the buildings in the Chicago skyline. The rest was created in Photoshop.

• The image size is 40 inches by 120 inches.

• The flattened file weighs in at 1.7 Gigabytes.

• It took eleven months (close to 2,000 hours) to create.

• The painting is comprised of close to fifty individual Photoshop files.

• Taking a cumulative total of all the files, the overall image contains over 15,000 layers.

• Over 500 alpha channels were used for various effects.

• Over 250,000 paths make up the multitude of shapes throughout the scene.

The realism is astounding, even minute close-up details.

Damen1.jpg

The front face of the train was created in its own file. The reflections in the windows were added once the train was placed in position within the overall image.

The side of the train car was created in a separate file. Duplicating that file made it easy to add additional cars.

The duplicates required changing the reflections in the windows, the accumulated grime and the car numbers to make each car appear different.

Every symbols, every piece of text and every logo you can see in this picture was created in Adobe Illustrator.

Damen2.jpg

The grime was created with Spatter brushes, available within the Photoshop brushes palette, which were modified to randomize the effect.

The rust was created with the same Spatter brushes but with Color Dynamics applied. The rust was in a separate layer that was also given a layer style of Inner Shadow to add the dimensional effect of the rust appearing under peeled paint.

Damen3.jpg

For comparison, here's the real thing.

damen-milwaukee11.jpg

This kind of artistry really makes you question what is real, and what is not.

YOu gave the one example I can't dispute, it looks real, but I guarantee a team of experts worked on this for a LONG time using real texture maps to "make" a photo. A real photo will ALWAYS look better, and I love photoshop and respect great skills. But there is no substitute for reality, the resolution and graphics are better!

And there are plug ins for rust and such, xenophex and alienskin products are amazing.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top