cjm
Member
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2010
- Messages
- 2,956
Spoiler Alert
Spoiler Alert
Spoiler Alert
Spoiler Alert
I went to the movie theater last night to see The Force Awakens and I was left with a feeling of Meh. I liked the Finn character and his reluctant hero vibe and that's about it.
Too many coincidences: they just happened to use the Millennium Falcon as their escape vehicle and then immediately Hans Solo found them.
Playing devil's advocate... Coincidences happen, and coincidences make for good stories sometimes. Keep in mind that the entire Star Wars universe is made up, so we could have an interesting story or a boring one. A coincidence makes for better story telling -- even if it wouldn't be super-believable in the real world.
Or when they go to some bar on a planet and Luke Skywalker's light saber happened to be there.
The proprietor in that series of scenes was supposed to be somewhat "connected." If the light saber wasn't there, the movie would have to take another 30 minutes to stumble upon the light saber in some other place. Better to combine the scenes and keep the story moving.
My biggest problem with the movie was the ending. I understand in any movie the concept of suspension of disbelief, but the ending was too unbelievable. Okay Kylo Ren has been training his whole life mastering the force. The guy can stop a plasma rifle round when it is shot at him, but yet he can't read Rey's mind because the force was strong with her. Kylo Ren also couldn't defeat Rey in a light saber fight and she had just discovered the power force literally that day, ridiculous.
Yeah, I was of the same opinion at first. But since I have mad Jedi rationalization skillz, try this on...
Kylo Ren was trained in the elitist dark side academies and never really faced a ruffian from the real world. So, plasma rifle was just like year two training at the academy. When he runs into something unexpected (gal from sand planet that resists his Vulcan mind meld), it throws him enough that his training can't compensate. He has demonstrated that he's conflicted, and this trivial information extraction throws him off. From Rey's point of view, she's plucked from the sand world that she knew and thrust into this crazy mess. Flight or fight response, spider senses tingling, now able to access "force" stuff that might not have been accessible before? Rey obviously had some blaster and hand-to-hand survival skills from her life pre-force. She took out three(?) trained sand troopers who were looking for BB-8 before she discovered her force-sensitivity. If she had good combat skills prior to force awakening, they'd only be heightened by the force -- maybe enough to take on this country club "force master"?