How RP answered the Tax question with Beck
I was confused by the tax question RP answered in the Glenn Beck interview, I see this as a key point to clearify for the next interview on "Meet the Press".
If only he had been given more time I am sure we would have heard the rest of his answer, but it left me worried how Beck's general audience would take this. Can anyone link me to how RP usually answers this complex question? (I'm pretty well versed in Austrian Economics, but he is making a careful straddle here between constitutionalism and a completely unhampered natural order society.)
Quote:
Beck: So -- so you want to replace it with -- with a -- with some sort of a sales tax?
PAUL: No, nothing.
BECK: Nothing. How...
PAUL: I want to replace it with freedom. I want to replace it with freedom and less spending.
BECK: OK. But wait a minute. Hang on just a second.
PAUL: But you`re right. Yes, OK.
BECK: I mean, I love you. Don`t get me wrong. How do we pay for the things we do have to pay for?
PAUL: Well, you know, if you didn`t have the income tax right now, you`d have the same amount of revenue as you had 10 years ago. So that`s not all that bad. And we didn`t have an income tax before 1913. They used -- they used tariffs and they used user fee types and different things like that.
BECK: But wouldn`t you create the same...
PAUL: The problem is spending.
BECK: Oh, I agree with you. But wouldn`t you create the same kind of situation if you had user fees? Because then you`d have special interests that were just saying, no, this one should be exempt and this one shouldn`t.
PAUL: Well, I guess so. But anything would be better than the income tax. But, you know, if you -- if we do have a user fee, which we abuse, you have a user fee by paying a national gasoline tax. And that`s supposed to take care of our highways, but they abuse that system, too.
BECK: Yes, yes.
PAUL: They don`t spend it on the highways, and they use it for political boondoggles is what happens.
BECK: Back in a minute with Dr. Paul`s controversial views on foreign policy, the CIA, FBI, the Patriot Act and the war on drugs. He`ll get more than 30 seconds to explain it all. Stick around.