Ron Paul, Jeff Flake, Mike Pence + 7 others Vote Nay on Pi Day Bill

Kregisen

Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2010
Messages
2,373
http://www.newscientist.com/blogs/shortsharpscience/2009/03/who-would-vote-against-pi-day.html

It's official! The US House of Representatives has recognised 14 March as Pi Day. Get it? 3/14. The ratio of the circumference of a circle to its diameter is roughly 3.14...That Pi Day.

My first thought was, "Sweet, another day off from work," until I realised that Pi Day falls on a Saturday this year.

Then I discovered that House Resolution 224 does not create a federal holiday, it merely "supports the designation of a 'Pi Day' and its celebration around the world" and "encourages schools and educators to observe the day with appropriate activities that teach students about Pi and engage them about the study of mathematics."

Unless a committee member snuck in a three-day weekend clause into the bill, like so many earmarks, I'm out of luck.

Even without a day off, the resolution passed overwhelmingly, 391-10. My first question was, who the heck voted against Pi Day? Is there an old-school Pythagorean caucus in Congress that sees numbers that can't be expressed as a whole number or the ratio of two whole numbers as a threat to national security? Perhaps.

Then a colleague reminded me that in 1897 the Indiana state legislature tried passing a bill declaring Pi as 3.2. I couldn't find a competing resolution declaring 2 March as Pi day, nor 3 February.

Twitter, the source of everything you need to know in 140 characters or less, proved more helpful. Thanks to a tip from a Congressional staffer, I found the feed of Utah Congressman Jason Chaffetz, AKA jasoninthehouse.

His latest tweet, as of 5:05 PM ET on Thursday, reads: "I cannot support Pi Day as just one day. It should go on forever. I voted "Nay." It passed 391-10."

Chaffetz previously tweeted his support for H.R. 224 yesterday afternoon: "Actually going to vote on supporting "Pi Day". Yes, as in 3.14. I have nothing against Pi, but hard to believe we have to vote on this."

Sounds like a flip-flop to me.

The other members voting Nay include: Jeff Flake, Republican from Arizona; Dean Heller, Republican from Montana; Timothy Johnson, Republican from Illinois; Jeff Miller, Republican from Florida; Randy Neugebauer, Republican from Texas; Ron Paul, a former presidential candidate and Republican from Texas; Ted Poe, another GOP member; Bill Shuster, a Republican from Pennsylvania; and last but most certainly not least, Mike Pence, a Republican from Indiana.

If any of these politicians represent your home district, please let them know how you feel about their snub of Pi Day. You can find your Congressman's phone number or e-mail address by looking them up here.


One of my friends who I've been trying to convert to Ron for a while told me about this today. I told him it's most likely a worthless bill that just wastes thousands of taxpayer dollars, but I can't find a source for how much it would cost. Does anyone know?

When Ron, Flake and Pence all vote no on this, you know it's not worth voting for.
 
http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bill.xpd?bill=hr111-224&tab=summary

H. Res. 224: Supporting the designation of Pi Day, and for other purposes

3/12/2009--Passed House without amendment. (This measure has not been amended since it was introduced. The summary of that version is repeated here.)

Supports the designation of a Pi Day and its celebration around the world.

Recognizes the continuing importance of National Science Foundation math and science education programs.

Encourages schools and educators to observe the day with appropriate activities that teach students about Pi and engage them about the study of mathematics.

He probably didn't want to vote in favor of recognizing "the continued importance" of an unconstitutional federal agency, or federal interference (even if it's just 'encouragement') into local schools.
 
Then a colleague reminded me that in 1897 the Indiana state legislature tried passing a bill declaring Pi as 3.2.

This is the very essence of government.
 
So Amash voted for this?


And how does Congress find time for this bullshit? Aren't they "hard at work tackling the nation's problems"?
 
I can no longer support Dr. Paul.

I completely agree. I agree with Dr. Paul on foreign policy, the Federal Reserve, and pretty much everything else, but this is absolute insanity that he would oppose this. I am going tomorrow to change my registration to Democratic so I can vote for Obama, who is a well-known pie supporter.
 
3.1415...

Congress should have waited until March 14, 2015, to declare Pi Day an official holiday, because then it would be a more accurate representation of Pi on that date--3/14/15.
 
Ron didn't support this because it mandates what must be taught to students on 3/14. Last time I checked, Ron doesn't support the federal government having ANYTHING to do with education. This is what you need to tell your buddy.
 
Back
Top