Since they don’t circulate and weren’t issued through banks, are silver eagle coins “legal tender” for all debts public and private, like paper money?
According to research done by Numismatic News*, even though the face value is well below the market price of US eagle coins, these coins are ‘legal tender’ for all debts public and private. The legal tender value is the amount printed on the coin (not the metallic value).
American Eagle coins are legal tender
In today’s market a person would be considered foolish to spend a silver eagle dollar for its $1.00 face value, although you could technically do so. However, why spend a silver eagle dollar for $1.00 when you could sell it for many times that for the silver that it contains?