parocks, in my estimation: it is a lot earlier than you think. Most people are not libertarians. They are thus not going to support the implementation of libertarianism. Because that's just not what they support.
You can drive yourself crazy trying to twist yourself in knots, invent brilliant sneaky strategies, fool people into electing libertarians, etc., but I do not think that is a lasting long-term strategy for success. The numbers just aren't there. It wouldn't make any sense for Ron Paul to get elected -- nor for Rand -- because most people just don't support what they support.
Most people aren't like us. We are a small minority. We aren't going to get success wearing ourselves out seeking political success from a populace which does not share our political views.
We succeed through self-improvement and education. Especially self-improvement. We have to be patient. Crazed impatience will drive you crazy, and eventually drive you to try things like lying and compromising your principles, and then of course you still won't succeed and so you'll go even crazier. I've seen it happen to people in the liberty movement.
Anyway, I personally wish that someone had done your free concerts and college-kids-GOTV idea. I think it was a great idea.
Did you read the Tom Woods "memories" piece?
There's been a Liberty Wing of the Republican Party since Robert Taft. What Ron Paul says isn't all that different from what Taft / Goldwater / Reagan said. Or what the Tea Party says they want. It's not a particularly new battle.
Those ideas - concerts / GOTV - require money.
One of the problems I had with superbrochures was that most of that money went to the USPS. Hundreds of thousands of dollars was spent, in total, by individuals, buying specific precincts, mailing these things to the targeted audience. What I thought should happen at the time was people on the ground would agree to deliver the superbrochure, door to door, and keeping that money, and using that money for projects like college/shows/GOTV.
My "free show" idea was really a time kill, a keep busy for meetup groups or any type of local organization. That idea was from last summer, when meetup groups or other local organizations didn't really have much to do except hold signs at an inappropriately early time. They could book a couple bands, pay them $100 a piece, decent local bands or decent touring bands, drawing a bit of people. and have people sign up, get some more names more organization, no big deal, not really difficult, and not really something that required any real expert skill to get done. And there might've been shows of that scale somewhere that I didn't know about. These wouldn't be the kind of thing that would be publicized here or anywhere outside a local area. This theme could work for almost anything. The problem with Ron Paul supporters, though, is they seem to be hard wired into certain ways of thinking about bands. 1) Free is best. 2) Songs about Ron Paul are best 3) Songs about Liberty are best. 4) The bands don't have to be good. 5) The bands don't have to be popular. And since my theory involved good, normal popular bands and not marginal bands singing Liberty songs for free, it didn't jump out at anybody as being a particularly good idea. Bands are seen as background music or as entertainment for Ron Paul supporters, but not a method to get normal people who like normal bands to start to like Ron Paul. Bands are for the converted, and not to convert. And the typical Ron Paul supporter does not see things the same way as I do at all in any case. Key point about "free show" is that it really was a meetup/local group building idea, for early, not really a GOTV thing.
The other GOTV/college/bands thing was different. That was something that should be organized and focused on, and could cost a decent amount of money. The core of that idea was getting people to the polls, and it included things like concerts at the polling place on election day on campuses. And something like that would include a conscious effort to try to get a great turnout, great results, in certain precincts, at certain caucuses. Big State Colleges. People in dorms. People in dorms telling people that a concert is taking place at the polling place right now. The point there wasn't to build meetup groups, keep meetup groups busy, it was to get votes. That would've been something that the official campaign could've put money into and set a reasonable target for votes, and tried to get those votes. Bands weren't the core to that idea, free beer at the bar next door to the polling place could've done the same thing. I was unable to find any evidence anywhere that we were able to reall kick ass at any college campus. We know that there are dorms with hundreds of people, or even thousands, and with money applied to those points, votes should've been generated. And it never happened.
I spent more time here talking about the college GOTV project, because I thought that it could really mean votes. The "free show" thing was really just about building meetups, and the merit and value of that is a little bit more amorphous, intangible, not directly related to getting votes.