Danke
Top Rated Influencer
- Joined
- Nov 6, 2007
- Messages
- 44,263
What..? Am I going to be like you if I do this diet?
Just do it and stop asking questions. If you don't like it, quit, pretty fucking simple.
What..? Am I going to be like you if I do this diet?
Just do it and stop asking questions. If you don't like it, quit, pretty fucking simple.
Ah, the irony of someone telling me to "stop asking questions" on a RPF board.
He could very well die immediately from starting the master cleanse route. People do not come from the same mold, they don't all fit one model, they can't be grouped together in situations like this.
Lets say he has diabetes, he could indeed die or cause serious and permanent damage within days of starting master cleanse. But wait, is it Type I or Type II diabetes, and is it in the early stages or late stages? That could make all the difference in the world as the the scale of the effect (if any)! If he stops taking insulin to go on this diet, he could cause permanent damage to his organ systems within 24 hours (or less), descend into a diabetic coma shortly thereafter, and die.
Asking questions saves lives, telling people to shut up and do it is a great way hurt people when dealing with a complex physiological system.
The idea that you think you can simplify diets to simple caloric intake reveals where the real ignorance lies. If all survival based on eating involved was taking calories in, I should be able to survive solely on a shots of vodka every day (1 shot has about 90 calories depending on the brand) I will quite quickly die from dehydration and/or alcohol poisoning.
What I'm saying is, this isn't a healthy thing. You're body isn't meant to be starved periodically.
At the end of the day, this is a starvation diet.
What, you can't read the many pages addressing all of this? Do you think you are going to die immediately from trying the MC after many have already said they were on it for over 4 weeks? Links to numerous resources also provided.
Let me repeat: Links to numerous resources also provided
Yeah, keep questioning and get no where, that's the ticket.
![]()
First of all, it was an analogy. Indeed you can survive on very few calories for very long periods of time if you have water. I could have made an equivalent analogy of a 2 liter bottle of Coke, where dehydration wasn't the immediate danger. The idea was to demonstrate that calories alone are not enough.
I'm also not sure what you mean by "quite a while." Maybe I'm looking at the wrong brands, but there's a distinct lack of Vitamin C in maple syrup. That's OK though, I hear scurvy isn't that bad. There also doesn't appear to be a whole lot of Vitamin B, but anemia isn't a real condition anyway.
I'm not trying to say that a 10 day deprivation of these, or indeed anything besides water will have effects temporarily or permanently. What I'm saying is, this isn't a healthy thing. You're body isn't meant to be starved periodically. You can probably recover every time, and you might not even be the worse off for it. I can also break my arm multiple times and let it heal and not be the worse off for it. In fact, people who practice various martial arts actually see benefits from breaking/shattering their hands repeatedly on wood/concrete. That information doesn't mean you should go punch the nearest brick wall you can find.
At the end of the day, this is a starvation diet. The majority of the weight lost is water weight, which is gained back as soon as the fasting stops. Other weight loss can be associated with the degradation of your lean muscle which your body consumes to compensate for the lack of nutrients in your diet. If you truly want to believe that you have pounds of buildup in your intestines, I won't be able to sway you simply by saying "that isn't true." Unfortunately I don't have journal articles at my fingertips to point to either, though I'll certainly be on the lookout when I have some free time. I can only say what I do based on experience, and I've seen quite a few colonoscopies (watch for yourself YouTube - 3 minutes Total Colonoscopy:TCS) and there's a disturbing lack of well...anything in a healthy colon. Any buildups are generally very small (on the order of ounces) and constitute quite a bit of pain. By the time things that can be digested reach your colon (e.g. meats) they're simply a wetter form of fecal matter. You're colon reabsorbs most of that moisture along with some nutrients and salts. There isn't a buildup of undigested meat in your colon, ruffage (some vegetables, fiber, etc.) is the only thing that passes through you essentially unchanged.
Ok, so I decided to try the master cleanse. I was going to start today but I'm not starting until Monday now because I have dinner plans tonight that I can't back out of (I tried). I did the salt water thing this morning and it was so disgusting! I divided it into two glasses to try and make it easier to drink. That didn't work. I plugged my nose and drank the first glass without any problems, but halfway through my second glass I threw up in the sink. I might try the salt water thing again on Monday if I forget how horrible it was.
This is a long thread that I would be a pain to read through, but drinking salt water can be harmful. I don't know how much salt you're using but if it's anything near sea water, you're doing harm to yourself.
I've never done colon cleansing intentionally before, but I know that there is a pasta-like seaweed product that we eat for Chinese New Year. It's called fat-choy and it's looks like black strands of hair. It's much thinner than angelhair pasta. After eating lots of it in soup and stir-fried with mushrooms, dried oysters, dried dates, and bok-choy or napa cabbage, I was completely cleared out. Like pasta, it expands when soaked in liquid, except your body doesn't completely digest it. So when it is in your stomach and intestines it scrapes your shit clean. I'll do some more research later.