You both are wrong, and couldn't be more wrong. The first round was great, kept you on the edge of your seat waiting for someone to explode. And Machida did that one time and hit Evans pretty hard a couple times in that one exchange. And, I'm a huge fan of Machida's fighting style. I didn't really see him doing anything different this fight than any other. He was elusive, and when he attacked it was with pin point precision. He doesn't "avoid them altogether". Rather he waits for the right time to strike and usually explodes when appropriate. The key to his fighting style is avoiding damage, and he accomplishes that with ease.
I'm always bothered by UFC fans who don't appreciate the art of fighting and just want to see a barn burner. Don't get me wrong, I love a good slug fest. One of my favorite fights is Don Frye Vs. Yoshihiro Takayama in Pride, absolutely amazing. However, I can appreciate all fighting styles and hate it when the crowd boos a good fight that is maybe going slower than they would wish. Annoys the hell out of me.