Is the new Arizona illegal immigration law a good way to reduce illegal immigration?

[tremendoustie]

Is the New Arizona illegal immigration law a good way to reduce illegal immigration?

Setting aside that we all know it's their right to enact the law- Is it a good law?

Not their right. Not a good law.

Probably will reduce immigration though, and increase emigration. Who wants to live in a police state?

 

[tremendoustie]

Really? Where's that statute?

Yes, nothing is true unless a government employee writes it down. Without government to define it for us, morality would not exist.

 

[tremendoustie]

And you do realize that Ron Paul isn't a proponent of open borders.....just sayin.

The open borders people and the anarchists should recognize that there are Republicans in the group who want the fucking borders enforced, and are happy to see a governor with enough spine to actually try to do something.

They can stomp their feet, bitch about racism, and whine endlessly about natural law, and they won't be saying anything I haven't heard before.

End the welfare state and I'll happily join the open borders lobby. Until then, I support the governor's position here.

Yes, because if we have the tyranny of the welfare state, we might as well have the tyranny of the police state to go along with it.

Papers please!

You're like the person who says, "I don't like government rules forcing hospitals to take you, but until we get rid of them, I support laws controlling what you many eat and drink, forcing you to exercise, and forcing you to buy insurance".

Instead of simply attempting to get rid of the problem, you support more tyranny to "fix" the ill effects of the first tyranny. Newsflash, if you haven't figured it out yet: the problems of tyranny never end. Each tyranny keeps "fixing" the problems of the last until you're a total serf.