GOP House candidate wants to stop immigration for 10 years

[Swordsmyth]

Freeze ALL immigration until Congress, both House AND Senate can come up with a comprehensive and rational process.

And then wait to implement it until we deal with the excess we already have.

 

[Stratovarious]

10 years sounds like a long time, I was thinking 5 years, but what's the rush , what does America
owe the world?
Nada , nadakngthing .

Lets go with Sword's idea, why put a limit on it, lets put out the stop losses and see where we are when
the dust settles.

 

[Stratovarious]

Freeze ALL immigration until Congress, both House AND Senate can come up with a comprehensive and rational process.

This sounds like permanent.

 

[PAF]

I could get behind a proposal that stipulates zero net immigration, coupled with requiring immigrants to take an IQ test and score above the current US average, and a requirement that you have to pay a certain amount of income tax (like 10x what the median US worker pays in a year) before becoming eligible for any social services.


But to just say no one can move to the US, under any circumstances, just doesn’t make sense.

^ This ^ on RonPaulForums... just doesn’t make sense.

 

[Krugminator2]

Immigration socialists: I don't know if Ludwig von Mises, Albert Einstein, and Ayn Rand will assimilate. Better keep them out. They are taking all the genius jobs from mediocre American workers.

The people who founded Google, eBay, Telsa, Intel and tons of other big companies that I can't think of off the top my head were founded by immigrants.

"In fact, 40% of the Fortune 500 was founded by immigrants or the children of immigrants. "
"Immigrants started 28.5% of all new businesses in 2014." https://www.inc.com/dustin-mckissen...-twice-as-likely-to-become-entrepreneurs.html

There is some middle ground on immigration. But keeping immigrants out for ten years is the kind of idea a 27 year who runs a blog that makes zero money and wants attention would come up with. Letting immigrants buy the right of entry just like they buy a house or college education is probably the best solution. They regulates immigration automatically based on the need in the economy.

I don't even really understand the argument for keeping any immigrant with a STEM degree out. The reality is college educated immigrants are much smarter and more industrious.

 

[phill4paul]

This sounds like permanent.

That'd be fine too.

 

[Swordsmyth]

Immigration socialists: I don't know if Ludwig von Mises, Albert Einstein, and Ayn Rand will assimilate. Better keep them out. They are taking all the genius jobs from mediocre American workers.

The people who founded Google, eBay, Telsa, Intel and tons of other big companies that I can't think of off the top my head were founded by immigrants.

"In fact, 40% of the Fortune 500 was founded by immigrants or the children of immigrants. "
"Immigrants started 28.5% of all new businesses in 2014." https://www.inc.com/dustin-mckissen...-twice-as-likely-to-become-entrepreneurs.html

There is some middle ground on immigration. But keeping immigrants out for ten years is the kind of idea a 27 year who runs a blog that makes zero money and wants attention would come up with. Letting immigrants buy the right of entry just like they buy a house or college education is probably the best solution. They regulates immigration automatically based on the need in the economy.

Another cash register libertarian.
It's not about economics, it's about political culture, you will lose all the economic benefit you imagine you will get and more when the unassimilating immigrants impose communism.

 

[Stratovarious]

That'd be fine too.

Yep, the safest times for America is also when Congress is not in session.

 

[Krugminator2]

Another cash register libertarian.
It's not about economics, it's about political culture, you will lose all the economic benefit you imagine you will get and more when the unassimilating immigrants impose communism.

Good point. The disproportionate number of immigrants who excel in STEM and entrepreneurship are a real drain on the culture. The toothless meth and opioid addicted real Americans are what give the country "culture" and make it great.

 

[Swordsmyth]

Good point. The disproportionate number of immigrants who excel in STEM and entrepreneurship are a real drain on the culture. The toothless meth and opioid addicted real Americans are what give the country "culture" and make it great.

Your biased Oikophobic view of Americans makes no difference, the immigrants vote for much larger government at much higher rates.

 

[phill4paul]

Rule#1:

No foreign trespasser will be granted any form of citizenship. Any foreign trespasser will immediately be deported, unless said trespasser has committed a felony in which case the trespasser will be prosecuted and, upon serving sentence, at hard labor, then be deported.

Rule #2:

No immigrant shall enter or be granted citizenship without first obtaining a U.S. sponsor. Either in the form of an individual or a charitable organization. Said sponsor will be responsible for the immigrants upkeep. This will include food, housing and education costs. Said sponsor will be responsible for any debt or liability incurred by their sponsorship.

 

[Stratovarious]

Immigration socialists: I don't know if Ludwig von Mises, Albert Einstein, and Ayn Rand will assimilate. Better keep them out. They are taking all the genius jobs from mediocre American workers.

The people who founded Google, eBay, Telsa, Intel and tons of other big companies that I can't think of off the top my head were founded by immigrants.

"In fact, 40% of the Fortune 500 was founded by immigrants or the children of immigrants. "
"Immigrants started 28.5% of all new businesses in 2014." https://www.inc.com/dustin-mckissen...-twice-as-likely-to-become-entrepreneurs.html

There is some middle ground on immigration. But keeping immigrants out for ten years is the kind of idea a 27 year who runs a blog that makes zero money and wants attention would come up with. Letting immigrants buy the right of entry just like they buy a house or college education is probably the best solution. They regulates immigration automatically based on the need in the economy.

I don't even really understand the argument for keeping any immigrant with a STEM degree out. The reality is college educated immigrants are much smarter and more industrious.

Brilliant observation.

Somalians (Somalis) ?
Haitians ?
MS 13 Members ?
Mid East Terrorist?
Socialist Liberals?

 

[Swordsmyth]

Rule#1:

No foreign trespasser will be granted any form of citizenship. Any foreign trespasser will immediately be deported, unless said trespasser has committed a felony in which case the trespasser will be prosecuted and, upon serving sentence, at hard labor, then be deported.

Rule #2:

No immigrant shall enter or be granted citizenship without first obtaining a U.S. sponsor. Either in the form of an individual or a charitable organization. Said sponsor will be responsible for the immigrants upkeep. This will include food, housing and education costs. Said sponsor will be responsible for any debt or liability incurred by their sponsorship.

Rule #3:

No visitor shall be allowed to enter the country without posting a bond that will cover the costs of his removal and a reward for someone turning him in should he overstay.

 

[PAF]

Rule#1:

No foreign trespasser will be granted any form of citizenship. Any foreign trespasser will immediately be deported, unless said trespasser has committed a felony in which case the trespasser will be prosecuted and, upon serving sentence, at hard labor, then be deported.

Rule #2:

No immigrant shall enter or be granted citizenship without first obtaining a U.S. sponsor. Either in the form of an individual or a charitable organization. Said sponsor will be responsible for the immigrants upkeep. This will include food, housing and education costs. Said sponsor will be responsible for any debt or liability incurred by their sponsorship.

I like part of the first sentence of #1, not including trespasser. Everything else is completely statist which Feeds the Fed.

Just sayin’

 

[Swordsmyth]

I like part of the first sentence of #1, not including trespasser. Everything else is completely statist which Feeds the Fed.

Just sayin’

The immigrants are statist and feed the fed.

 

[Anti Federalist]

Freeze ALL immigration until Congress, both House AND Senate can come up with a comprehensive and rational process.

They had one, signed by the most libertarian president ever, and it worked, very well, for over 40 years.

Until the beginning of the end in 1965.

Repeal Hart-Celler and reset the clock to the Immigration Act of 1924.

Simple, legal, constitutional and effective.

And will never happen.

 

[Anti Federalist]

Immigration socialists: I don't know if Ludwig von Mises, Albert Einstein, and Ayn Rand will assimilate. Better keep them out. They are taking all the genius jobs from mediocre American workers.

But they weren't...kept out that is.

So, repeal Hart-Celler and reset the clock back to the rules under the Immigration Act of 1924.

I'm willing to compromise on that.

The people who founded Google, eBay, Telsa, Intel and tons of other big companies that I can't think of off the top my head were founded by immigrants.

Not a fan of a single one of those rent seeking surveillance corps.

 

[Todd]

You would lose.

But thanks for exposing your America hate.

Lol. You are a fucking collectivist looney. American's can't even find Mexico on a map and I'm an American hater. Dumbass.

 

[Swordsmyth]

Lol. You are a $#@!ing collectivist looney. American's can't even find Mexico on a map and I'm an American hater. Dumbass.

LOL
The collectivist calling all Americans dumb and all immigrants brilliant is calling me a collectivist.

Just keep exposing your hatred for your countrymen.

 

[Todd]

LOL
The collectivist calling all Americans dumb and all immigrants brilliant is calling me a collectivist.

Just keep exposing your hatred for your countrymen.

You’re reading comprehension skills are pretty shitty. What is it about me surmising foreign IQ are probably higher than “most”...meaning many....lots....not ALL dipshit?

Pathetic propagandists