Good Career choices: Should I become a Geologist or an Electrician?

Funny thing about all this is if I were to follow my heart I'd probably do something involving marine fish. I love scuba diving and ever since I was a kid have been completely fascinated with sea life. Part of the reason I want to do Geology is as a compromise: I could live somewhere warm where I get to scuba dive often, but still make more money than a marine biologist.
 
Question for everyone: should I become a geologist or an electrician? I finished my undergrad a couple of years ago and was working in sales. However, the stress of selling something no one needs got to me and now I'm looking to make a switch. I have a family friend that has a connection for me in the local Industrial Electrical Union that could probably get me a job as an apprentice. The alternative is I continue studying for my GRE and go to graduate school for geology. I am worried about wages/the economy for both. I know geologists are doing well but what if prices collapse? Also, if I become an electrician, it's possible the industrial places I end up working could close down in a collapse.

Any advice? Thanks!

What in HELL would you do as a geologist?

Electrician all the way if you are of a practical bent.
 
What in HELL would you do as a geologist?

Electrician all the way if you are of a practical bent.

Work for one of the many mining/oil/gas companies? Work for environmental consulting companies? Work for the government in environmental roles? Many different things you could do with the designation.
 
Funny thing about all this is if I were to follow my heart I'd probably do something involving marine fish. I love scuba diving and ever since I was a kid have been completely fascinated with sea life. Part of the reason I want to do Geology is as a compromise: I could live somewhere warm where I get to scuba dive often, but still make more money than a marine biologist.

They need electricity in warm places too! And there's absolutely nothing stopping you from studying marine biology on the side. I think you'll be amazed that you'll be able to learn more marine biology on your own than in a structured education. It can also leave your mind far more open.
 
Funny thing about all this is if I were to follow my heart I'd probably do something involving marine fish. I love scuba diving and ever since I was a kid have been completely fascinated with sea life. Part of the reason I want to do Geology is as a compromise: I could live somewhere warm where I get to scuba dive often, but still make more money than a marine biologist.

There you go: Offshore wildcatter! You are closer to your goal than you think!

For me, I'd stick with Geology. If you have any desire for adventure wildcat positions hold a lot of promise and most people don't want to engage in this work. Personally, I work in heavy earthwork so I get where you are coming from with the Geology degree. One thing you might want to consider is going for a MS in Geological Engineering or Geotechnical Engineering as opposed to a straight degree in Geology. Might offer more employment options over the course of your career.

Just my .02
 
Funny thing about all this is if I were to follow my heart I'd probably do something involving marine fish. I love scuba diving and ever since I was a kid have been completely fascinated with sea life. Part of the reason I want to do Geology is as a compromise: I could live somewhere warm where I get to scuba dive often, but still make more money than a marine biologist.

You could just tell people that you're a marine biologist. What could possibly go wrong?


 
I don't know a lot of electricians making $400k per year...

If there are so many surplus geologists how come they are so well paid and have so many open jobs?
 
Both. Geothermal power plant.

Specialize in volcanology studies while learning the basics with a part time electrical labor job.

And if you get the Hawaii gig, you can live in a warm climate. :)

I worked electrical labor for almost two years and learned enough to be a danger to both myself and others -and I live on an active volcano.

I'm sure you could do much better if you applied yourself.:D;)

http://www.punageothermalventure.com/PGV/16/equipment-technology

PGV, the only commercial geothermal power plant in the state, is in the Puna District of Hawai‘i Island. It’s located about 21 miles south of Hilo. The facility is situated on about 30 acres of a 500-acre plot along the Lower East Rift Zone (LERZ) of the Kilauea Volcano.

Powered by natural heat from the earth, PGV’s power plant has provided stable, sustainable electricity for the Big Island of Hawaii for more than a decade. The plant generates about 20 percent of the electrical energy—and energy diversification—to that market under a Power Purchase Agreement with HELCO.

pgv.jpg
binaryplant.gif
 
Last edited:
http://www.seg.org/careers/employees/view-jobs/joblist

tons of jobs, not...

stable, good $$$, work with hands = electrician
unstable, travel, good $$$, cog in a wheel or government whore = geologist

-Why would you say it's unstable? What about all the electricians I'm reading about that are out of work due to the housing bust? I live in Canada so I really don't know about what the trades are experiencing down there vs here, but housing is WAY overpriced up here and I know a bust will happen soon so I want to pick right.

-Electricians can be brought in from third world countries (look at Dubai) and paid almost nothing. I know there are more regulations over here but that doesn't mean it couldn't happen.

-Regarding the cost of schooling: it's almost free to do a Masters because the school pays you a stipend or gives you a TA position teaching students.

-I'd like to move to: Australia, Europe, US (California/Florida/Colorado) - not in any particular order but I want to know that it's possible with whatever career I choose.
 
Funny, it's like this thread was tailor-made for me. I have a physics and electronics background, and my first career move was with a mineral exploration geophysics (resistivity and magnetometer surveys).

If you are creative and ambitious, really good at what you do, and focus on applied geology/geophysics, and specifically exploration, and try to avoid dependency on the academic publicly funded "vacuum" side of geology (except as it increases your knowledge in an applied field), your knowledge and ingenuity can translate to real power, and you can make a LOT of money.

If you have geology as a major with a minor in electrical engineering (NOT electrician, but actual electrical engineering), your value as a geologist skyrockets, as you become a specialized breed. Even if you don't apply your knowledge as an entrepreneur, your value to firms like mineral exploration EQUIPMENT companies cannot be underestimated.

Minerals of all kinds are becoming increasingly scarce as an exponential trend that has been maturing for some time, so there really is no shortage of opportunities in applied geology and geophysics.

Hence, I like the suggestion that said "can't you do both?". You can. Simultaneously -- and you multiply your fall-back opportunities.

The thing I consider the most important of all is the quality of life, over and above security or average income for a field. Being an electrician is hard work, and electricians, for as much as they can make, are not that scarce, given that the requirements to work in that field open it up to a lot more competitors. On top of that, the work really is, by and large, mundane. Plus, if you're not planning to be a contractor with employees, ways to multiply or have a vested interest in anything you do are limited. You'll just be trading time for money.

My opinion, were I in your position:

Geology/geophysics (Masters), with a minor (BSEE) in electrical engineering. Do that and you're solid gold, set for life.
 
Back
Top