Don't Take Tickets from Romney

I agree. There's nothing legally binding by signing that pledge.

But, as you well know, legal and moral are often two different things.

Question. I wonder if it would be illegal because it isn't A REAL ELECTION. This is a fundraiser, not the real election. so maybe it would be legal to have people sign the contract to vote for said individual. Can't scream election fraud when it isn't really an election; only can scream fraud.
 
I think it's funny that the topic creator sees taking tickets from Romney and voting for Paul as a matter of integrity. But simply put. Giving away free tickets and putting people on a bus to the event is also a matter of bad integrity too.
 
Question. I wonder if it would be illegal because it isn't A REAL ELECTION. This is a fundraiser, not the real election. so maybe it would be legal to have people sign the contract to vote for said individual. Can't scream election fraud when it isn't really an election; only can scream fraud.

Well, I see what you are saying, but any contract by definition has to have a measure of validation, there would be no way for a pledge to be "validated" or audited or otherwise assessed on a per pledge basis.

Also, a pledge is a somewhat loose term but I have never seen it used as a legally binding contract. Everything I am seeing categorizes a pledge as a moral, not a legal commitment. It also depends on what you are actually signing. ;)
Ron Paul’s supporters are actively encouraging Iowa voters to take advantage of Mitt Romney’s offers of free transportation to the Iowa Straw Poll in Ames on Saturday and then, once they are there, to vote for Mr. Paul.

“Some say if Mitt is willing to bus Iowans to Ames for the straw poll, they should take him up on his offer!” says a flier in Iowa and on the Internet in advance of the straw poll for the Republican presidential candidates. The flier says that after riding the Romney bus to Ames, and allowing the Romney campaign to pay one’s $35 entry fee, Iowans should then carefully weigh their options and “they may decide to vote for Ron Paul.”

The flier is topped with a banner that says “2008 Ron Paul News,” but Jesse Benton, a campaign spokesman, said it was the handiwork of independent supporters over whom the campaign had no control. “We can’t tell our supporters what to do or not do,” Mr. Benton said, adding that the campaign did not want to get “entangled” with federal finance regulations involving potential in-kind contributions.

But he conceded that infiltrating the Romney bus could certainly help Mr. Paul. It is his first visible attempt at converting his popularity online into success offline, which, alas, is where it counts.


Some quasi-related links...
When is a pledge legally binding?

Sponsor Suit on No-Buy Pledges Allowed

No More Pledge Cards
 
Last edited:
Back
Top