Black Georgia Democrat legislator switches parties over school choice

jmdrake

Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2007
Messages
51,897
The republicans who broke rank to vote against school choice deserve to be tarred and feathered.

https://apnews.com/article/mesha-ma...tch-democrat-a725f1c3d5e827a05a95eb178194f80e

ATLANTA (AP) — A Georgia state legislator from Atlanta switched to the Republican Party on Tuesday, after being at odds with Democrats for reasons including her support for school vouchers and disciplining prosecutors.

Rep. Mesha Mainor becomes the only Black member of the GOP among Georgia’s 236 state lawmakers, and the first Black Republican woman to ever serve in the Georgia General Assembly. Mainor’s defection gives Republicans a 102-78 edge in the House.

Mainor said legislative Democrats drove her out of the party for breaking party orthodoxy, claiming at a Tuesday news conference outside the Georgia Capitol that they had “relentlessly tried to sabotage every single thing that I have done for District 56” and “publicly slandered me in every way imaginable.”

“I thought it was OK to not agree with those things as a Democrat. But they told me, ‘You know what, those are values we just don’t have,’” Mainor said, flanked by state Republican Party Chairman Josh McKoon.

But she had long been on the outs as part of a minority faction of Atlanta-area Democrats and for deeply personal reasons revolving around a stalking incident where Mainor felt her stalker got off too easy.

The tension between Mainor and other Democrats burst into the open earlier this year after Mainor became the only Democrat to vote for a school voucher bill that failed after a number of House Republicans broke ranks to oppose it. School choice has always had some support among urban Black Democrats, but Mainor’s fellow party members reacted with scorn even as Republicans rallied to Mainor’s support. State Sen. Josh McLaurin, an Atlanta Democrat, posted a picture of a $1,000 check online for a primary challenger, writing “All I need is a name.”

Mainor, first elected in 2020, represents House District 56, an ultra-Democratic swath of Atlanta including its Midtown neighborhood and close-in parts of the city’s west side. She had said earlier that she wouldn’t switch parties. Tuesday, though, she urged other lifelong Democrats to reexamine the party’s values.

“I am encouraging more Black Americans and Black Democrats in particular – you might have this coat on, but I suggest you look at the lining. See what’s on the inside,” she said.

McKoon welcomed Mainor, saying her move shows that the Republican Party is “where diversity of opinion is welcome, where different ideas, talking about different policy ideas and solutions together is a strength, not a weakness.”

“We can disagree but still come together on things that matter the most to us,” McKoon said, pledging to support Mainor’s reelection bid.

U.S. Rep. Nikema Williams, chair of the Democratic Party of Georgia, lambasted Mainor’s switch as a “stinging betrayal” of her Democratic constituents.

“House District 56 deserves a representative who will do the job they were elected to do, including fight for high-quality public education,” Williams said in a statement.

House Speaker Jon Burns, a Republican from Newington, said in a statement that Mainor is “joining the party of opportunity.”

Mainor’s decision and some of her legislative actions are also driven by a much more personal dispute. She sued Fulton County Commissioner Marvin Arrington Jr., Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis and the county in federal court in 2022, alleging that they had violated her civil rights in a case where a former campaign worker had stalked her.

Willis claimed Arrington, who was the man’s defense attorney, improperly used his position as a commissioner to get a favorable plea deal for the stalker. Mainor also alleged Willis didn’t adequately investigate the crime before offering the plea deal. U.S. District Judge Sarah Geraghty dismissed the case in March, ruling that the alleged actions couldn’t constitute a civil rights violation even if she accepted all of Mainor’s claims.

The last legislative Democrat in Georgia to switch to the Republican Party was DeKalb County’s Vernon Jones, who plunged into the GOP in January 2021 as a supporter of then-President Donald Trump, at the end of Jones’ last term in the state House. Jones abandoned a Republican primary challenge to Gov. Brian Kemp at Trump’s behest and then lost a Republican congressional primary runoff in Georgia’s 10th District to current U.S. Rep. Mike Collins despite Trump’s backing.​
 
I don't think she switched because she prefers the GOP as much as it was that the democrats threatened to primary her because of a vote where she broke party lines. Unlikely in her district that a republican would even bother to run against a democrat so now she's pretty much got the primary to herself.

 
I don't think she switched because she prefers the GOP as much as it was that the democrats threatened to primary her because of a vote where she broke party lines. Unlikely in her district that a republican would even bother to run against a democrat so now she's pretty much got the primary to herself.



I didn't say she preferred the GOP. But she clearly agreed with the GOP on the school choice issue and the Democrats are so hard core pro teachers union that they don't want to budge.

Quick anecdote. When Trump was first elected I was having lunch with another black friend of mine. The news was talking about how much Democrats hated Trump's education secretary Betsy DeVos because she supported expansion of charter schools. He was agreeing that she was terrible. Then I asked him this question. "Doesn't your daughter attend a charter school?" He got quiet and went back to eating his lunch. Everybody is paying attention to the Supreme Court affirmative action decision. But that only affects a few blacks at the END of the education pipeline. The school choice issue affects blacks at the BEGINNING of the education pipeline. The big question I have, and your video brought out briefly is, why the hell did 14 Republicans vote against school choice?
 
The big question I have, and your video brought out briefly is, why the hell did 14 Republicans vote against school choice?

We do have some pretty lousy republican politicians in this state. When you border Florida, the contrast is pretty stark. We tried to vote the spineless ones out in the last primaries, but I think open primaries screwed us with all the crossovers. (Florida has closed primaries, I believe)
 
why the hell did 14 Republicans vote against school choice?
[MENTION=849]jmdrake[/MENTION]

Good question...let me find a list of names and look.

ETA - Last year they did the same thing.
 
Last edited:
[MENTION=849]jmdrake[/MENTION]

Good question...let me find a list of names and look.
Republican defectors included Reps. Matt Barton of Calhoun, Beth Camp of Concord, J. Collins of Villa Rica, Lehman Franklin of Statesboro, Gerald Greene of Cuthbert, David Huddleston of Roopville, Eddie Lumsden of Armuchee, Danny Mathis of Cochran, Don Parsons of Marietta, Mitchell Scoggins of Cartersville, Tyler Paul Smith Bremen, Vance Smith of Pine Mountain, Darlene Taylor of Thomasville, Ken Vance of Milledgeville and Bill Yearta of Sylvester.

https://georgiarecorder.com/2023/03...r-private-schools-non-starter-in-state-house/

My republican critter voted yes. There are a lot of under-performing schools in my district. It's not just the poor black kids but the poor white kids ain't doing great either. As much as I'm generally opposed to public dollars being used to support private institutions (thereby in my view, making them de-facto public), I realize home-schooling isn't really an option for kids whose parents can't help them at all with things like algebra, reading beyond 5th grade level, or biology/chemistry.

Don't think we have a teacher's union in Georgia but there is still a strong lobby for them.
 
Last edited:
https://georgiarecorder.com/2023/03...r-private-schools-non-starter-in-state-house/

My republican critter voted yes. There are a lot of under-performing schools in my district. It's not just the poor black kids but the poor white kids ain't doing great either. As much as I'm generally opposed to public dollars being used to support private institutions (thereby in my view, making them de-facto public), I realize home-schooling isn't really an option for kids whose parents can't help them at all with things like algebra, reading beyond 5th grade level, or biology/chemistry.

Don't think we have a teacher's union in Georgia but there is still a strong lobby for them.

Thanks for the link. Looks like the bill as written would have helped home schoolers too.


The bill would have given $6,500 to the families of Georgia public school students in the bottom 25% of schools who pulled their children out of class to attend private school or study at home. A last-minute amendment Wednesday afternoon stipulated that the state would decrease the scholarship amount in years that the state did not fully fund its share of the state’s education spending formula.

I was homeschooled my 8th grade year. It was correspondence school as in I wrote letters back and forth to the teachers. For math class the lectures were pre-recorded on cassette tape. With the use of the Internet, the possibility of homeschoolers getting classroom level instruction is even greater.
 
Thanks for the link. Looks like the bill as written would have helped home schoolers too.


The bill would have given $6,500 to the families of Georgia public school students in the bottom 25% of schools who pulled their children out of class to attend private school or study at home. A last-minute amendment Wednesday afternoon stipulated that the state would decrease the scholarship amount in years that the state did not fully fund its share of the state’s education spending formula.

I was homeschooled my 8th grade year. It was correspondence school as in I wrote letters back and forth to the teachers. For math class the lectures were pre-recorded on cassette tape. With the use of the Internet, the possibility of homeschoolers getting classroom level instruction is even greater.

My younger sister was homeschooled and tried one of those online programs and it was a bit of a gimmick. I don't think she got much out of it. I think there is something to be said for in-person instruction, but also I recognize that no two kids have the same needs or the same preferred learning methods.
 
My younger sister was homeschooled and tried one of those online programs and it was a bit of a gimmick. I don't think she got much out of it. I think there is something to be said for in-person instruction, but also I recognize that no two kids have the same needs or the same preferred learning methods.

A few years ago everybody in America as online. I'm not saying that was optimal for everyone, but that's why thee key phrase is "school choice." I can say the home study course I did was not a gimmick. It was Home Study Institute, a program desinged for the children of SDA missionaries and it rigorous enough to make sure where the child might mainstream in the world he would not be behind. In 8th grade U.S. history, for example, we went from Christopher Columbus to Jimmy Carter, and we didn't cover Reagan because he wasn't in our print. By contrast U.S. high school and college was a breeze. (I actually knew more U.S. history than my high school teacher).

For African American families, homeschooling is one of the best ways to get past the so called "achievement gap."

http://www.afrometrics.org/research...ce-and-favorable-social-and-academic-outcomes
Ray’s (2015) study found that Black homeschool students scored at or above the 50th percentile in reading, math, language, and core (i.e. a combination of reading, language, and math) subtests. Students’ gender and their family’s household income had little effect on achievement scores (Ray, 2015). Black public school students scored at or below the 30th percentile in the same areas.

Although research shows that Black students in public schools generally score far below the national average, the Black homeschool students performed as well or better than the national average of public school students across all races and ethnicities (Ladson-Billings, 2006; Ray, 2015). In Ray’s (2015) study, not only were the scores of Black homeschool students far above the national average, but home education was shown to be a significant and consistent predictor of higher levels of achievement . While Ray’s (2015) study certainly breaks ground in empirically documenting the outcomes of Black home based education, as an explanatory non-experimental study it was not designed to establish causation. Nevertheless, it provides a launching pad for further research into the causal outcomes of homeschooling as well as considerations of appropriate policies related to home based education for African Americans.​
 
Back
Top