Times of Israel: ‘When Genocide Is Permissible’

[willwash]

What is your take on Hitler's "war" against Jews few decades back?

My take is, they started it:

 

[osan]

All else equal, I agree with the quote. If I'm minding my own, just trying to get along and some group attempts to destroy me, I am well within my right to kill them to the man, if that is what it takes to survive the threat. If I had to kill 1.3 billion Muslims to protect my child, I would do it in a heartbeat and not lose a moment's sleep. People need to learn how to behave properly.

 

[enhanced_deficit]

All else equal, I agree with the quote. If I'm minding my own, just trying to get along and some group attempts to destroy me, I am well within my right to kill them to the man, if that is what it takes to survive the threat. If I had to kill 1.3 billion Muslims to protect my child, I would do it in a heartbeat and not lose a moment's sleep. People need to learn how to behave properly.

EM.
You have amazing convictions. A question to test the strength of these convictions; hypothetically if a Nazi stated that he/she would kill 6 million jews to protect his/her child, would you be understanding of that view and would you agree with it? Would you yourself make the same statement by substituting the religion in your above statement?

 

[ClydeCoulter]

It's a though it's all being done on purpose. As though creating enemies that will attack the regime of Zionists is to bring about things that people have believed will happen because of prophecy. As though, the final solution is "Never again, again", and the gates of hell will prevail against any who dare oppose any who call them..."anti-Semite".

 

[A. Havnes]

As an advocate for non-violent resistance as a solution to conflict, I can't say that I agree with this author. However, I hope that the US decides to leave well-enough alone, and if either side decides to just go out and annihilate an entire group of people that we will stay out of it and not supply such weaponry to these people. Let them fight it out all on their own.

That doesn't mean not to have sympathy or empathy or one side or even both, nor does it mean you can't have judgements or go involve yourself in the conflict on your own accord; it just means that I don't want my tax dollars going to fund a cause that lobbyists want funded. I don't want my stolen money to be used for another nation's war.

 

[osan]

EM.
You have amazing convictions. A question to test the strength of these convictions; hypothetically if a Nazi stated that he/she would kill 6 million jews to protect his/her child, would you be understanding of that view and would you agree with it?

I most certainly would. As to whether 6 million Jews posed a direct and immediate threat to Mr. Nazi... that is a practical question, whereas that which I posited lives mainly in the world of theory and principle.

Would you yourself make the same statement by substituting the religion in your above statement?

What religion? I do not follow.

There are two aspects to this, the principled and the practical. In principle, I would indeed wipe from the earth every last breathing soul to protect my child. Coming down to actualities, there is a but more to things. Firstly, the chances that a billion people will pose such a clear, present, and direct threat to my child is... um... oh shit... Was going to say "unlikely", but I suppose that may have changed as of late.

Secondly, in most situations there may be some question as to how one determines whether a given individual poses such a threat.

But if we assume such a threat existed and in such numbers, that I had the means of defense, and that I could well determine who posed the threat vis-a-vis who did not, I stand by my word that I would slaughter them to the man without compunction, hesitation, of plague of conscience. As far as I am concerned, every man holds such a right in principle.

 

[osan]

It's a though it's all being done on purpose. As though creating enemies that will attack the regime of Zionists is to bring about things that people have believed will happen because of prophecy. As though, the final solution is "Never again, again", and the gates of hell will prevail against any who dare oppose any who call them..."anti-Semite".

I've marinaded in jewish culture most of my life mainly because there is tons of it right here in 'Murka. Being of NYC vintage, the marinade was trebly concentrated. There is more, but I will not expound.

Jews are generally very shrewd folks. They tend to see deeply into the essence of things and I believe the structure and nature of the culture is based on this. It requires no feat of rocket surgery to see what happens during good times: people become lazy and drift apart and dilute. If you want your culture to retain its vigorous cohesion, then you must stick together. The only way to keep people from drifting from one another is strife. When there is an enemy afoot and about, the wagons remain circled. This is clearly what Jews have been doing for a very long time. It is a time-tested method for maintaining social/cultural cohesion. Just enough fear to keep you close to family and friends at all times because "Theye" are out there and will get you if you are not vigilant.

I have all the respect in the world for the ways in which this has been carried forth, even if I despise the specific tactics. It is an eminently sound strategy for achieving the goals at hand.

I would add that, given the ways in which the Roman church directed their "flock" to treat Jews for a good 1200 years and more, can you blame those of that race for holding the goyim in contempt and perhaps even striving to position themselves such that they stand materially superior to the rest? I certainly cannot. Were I in the position, I would become a global banker and would own the world the way I own the fob on my pocket watch. You have two strikes against you as it is, may as well dispense with playing all nice. FTW.

 

[enhanced_deficit]

Well ehnahnced_deficit, this may be hard to explain to you since you deny the Holocaust ..

This is as accurate as saying that OReich drinks blood of Palestinian babies for breakfast every morning and OReich believes that Jewish people are going to burn in Hell for all of eternity unless they abandon Judaism and convert to Christianity. Or as credible as saying that OReich worships Andrew Adler.

If you choose to repeat false claims in future about others whose views you don't lik , you better attach evidence or your post will be reported to mods.

 

[Ronin Truth]

When you hate a group of people with something in common, enough, to just kill them all.

 

[enhanced_deficit]

On a related note, there is growing evidence that Israel did it all it could to stop ISIS from enagaging in genocide.

Genocide of Christians ramps up in Syria



Potentially Related

[h=1]Man accused of genocide to sleep in Trump’s bed in Israel[/h]