A rope leash
Member
- Joined
- Nov 9, 2007
- Messages
- 221
Welcome to the pile on!
"Actully, the communists do."
Thanks for pointing this out again, Laughingcow. Check out my response to it back on page four or 5ive. Maybe I should have said "Western history..."!
Yes, the commies are ruthless bastards that hate god and religion. It has nothing to do with the scam nature of many religions, people like the red Chinese are just evil. (sarcasm detectors on, please) Never mind that they've been in the civilization business for about ten times as long as we have. As far as I know, there aren't any piled up Christian bodies...as I've asked before, is there any evidence you can link me to that validates the claim that communists kill Christians on a regular basis simply for being Christian? Did the Soviets do this? I am aware of churches being outlawed and shut down, but not of any holocaust of god-believers.
But, yeah ya got me and ya got me good. Now, these evil atheist countries have supressed god and stifled his representatives. What has god done to smite them? Give them our jobs?
I'm not much for ruthless dictatorships, but if all men are equal, then so are all cultures. The Russians and the Chinese have been around and will stay around, apparently without the "necessity" of religion. You can say that communism supressed religion, but there wasn't any bloody war over it. Anyone can have a "relationship with god", it doesn't take a church, so any true believer would have went silent under the oppression, yet would have kept his heart aware.
Communism is not really a form of government so much as it is an economic system, one that tends to leave a lot of power in a very few hands. What should be said is that after they were put in power by popular revolutions, atheist communist dictators shut down religion in places like Russia and China, and no one complained much. I'm sure there are stories of priests and monks tortured to death by evil communists (please link me) but I don't think we are speaking of anything approaching the sort of wholesale genocide found in such western historical bygones as The Crusades, Manifest Destiny, or the Nazi exterminations.
Our current cultural excursions by force are tainted with the bitterness of Jews and Christians occupying and fighting Muslims. By some estimates, our sanctions and wars against Iraq have killed more than a million Iraqis. That's a million Muslims who died because of the militaristic meddlings of a "Christian nation". Compare this to communist suppression of religion, and a little Tibetian knock-down doesn't seem so awful.
Okay, don't get me wrong, I'm not apolgozing for despots. Freedom means y'all can believe whatever you wish. It does not, however, mean you should be allowed to proceed with a scam...and that, as I understand it, is part of the reasoning behind the shutdown of religion in communist countries. I don't think communists are inherently evil, and I don't think they are worried much about religion usurping their power, and I pretty much know they are not actively engaged in any war with the religious. They just want a peaceful culture, like anyone else. As atheists, they see that religion can lead to stupid shit like suicide bombs and abortion clinic shoot 'em ups. Yep, they probably go a bit overboard sometimes in denouncing it, but there aren't exactly hoardes of believers out there protesting about it, either. I imagine it's a bit like the drug war over here...it doesn't really stop anyone from doing what they really want to do if they really want to do it.
But, yeah, I misspoke. If it's a choice between the stake or the rack, I'll take the rack...
"Actully, the communists do."
Thanks for pointing this out again, Laughingcow. Check out my response to it back on page four or 5ive. Maybe I should have said "Western history..."!
Yes, the commies are ruthless bastards that hate god and religion. It has nothing to do with the scam nature of many religions, people like the red Chinese are just evil. (sarcasm detectors on, please) Never mind that they've been in the civilization business for about ten times as long as we have. As far as I know, there aren't any piled up Christian bodies...as I've asked before, is there any evidence you can link me to that validates the claim that communists kill Christians on a regular basis simply for being Christian? Did the Soviets do this? I am aware of churches being outlawed and shut down, but not of any holocaust of god-believers.
But, yeah ya got me and ya got me good. Now, these evil atheist countries have supressed god and stifled his representatives. What has god done to smite them? Give them our jobs?
I'm not much for ruthless dictatorships, but if all men are equal, then so are all cultures. The Russians and the Chinese have been around and will stay around, apparently without the "necessity" of religion. You can say that communism supressed religion, but there wasn't any bloody war over it. Anyone can have a "relationship with god", it doesn't take a church, so any true believer would have went silent under the oppression, yet would have kept his heart aware.
Communism is not really a form of government so much as it is an economic system, one that tends to leave a lot of power in a very few hands. What should be said is that after they were put in power by popular revolutions, atheist communist dictators shut down religion in places like Russia and China, and no one complained much. I'm sure there are stories of priests and monks tortured to death by evil communists (please link me) but I don't think we are speaking of anything approaching the sort of wholesale genocide found in such western historical bygones as The Crusades, Manifest Destiny, or the Nazi exterminations.
Our current cultural excursions by force are tainted with the bitterness of Jews and Christians occupying and fighting Muslims. By some estimates, our sanctions and wars against Iraq have killed more than a million Iraqis. That's a million Muslims who died because of the militaristic meddlings of a "Christian nation". Compare this to communist suppression of religion, and a little Tibetian knock-down doesn't seem so awful.
Okay, don't get me wrong, I'm not apolgozing for despots. Freedom means y'all can believe whatever you wish. It does not, however, mean you should be allowed to proceed with a scam...and that, as I understand it, is part of the reasoning behind the shutdown of religion in communist countries. I don't think communists are inherently evil, and I don't think they are worried much about religion usurping their power, and I pretty much know they are not actively engaged in any war with the religious. They just want a peaceful culture, like anyone else. As atheists, they see that religion can lead to stupid shit like suicide bombs and abortion clinic shoot 'em ups. Yep, they probably go a bit overboard sometimes in denouncing it, but there aren't exactly hoardes of believers out there protesting about it, either. I imagine it's a bit like the drug war over here...it doesn't really stop anyone from doing what they really want to do if they really want to do it.
But, yeah, I misspoke. If it's a choice between the stake or the rack, I'll take the rack...