The Good Side of Alexander Hamilton

[Galileo Galilei]

You still haven't offered anything to make a case for an imminent threat of war between the states following nine states ratifying the constitution. You are rolling a bunch of shit off of your keyboard and wrapping it up with a little personal insult. How about actually making a coherent case to support your assertion(s)...

Regarding your ignorant Articles of Confederation remark... I am not affiliated with monopoly and coercion.

There was already a war going on, between Pennsyvania and Connecticut. That alone disproves your thesis. Shay's rebellion happened. You made your thesis before you got the facts. You read some slanted history and decided it was true before analyzing all points of view. Give up the ghost.

 

[Galileo Galilei]

I already addressed Hamilton's federalist view on taxation in his own words.

Hamilton never supported an income tax. He opposed the income tax by signing the Constitution, which prohibits and income tax.

This fact alone makes Hamilton small government by today's standards.

My point is that people here need to stop complaining about Hamilton, and start complaining about people today who enable the income tax.

 

[Live_Free_Or_Die]

There was already a war going on, between Pennsyvania and Connecticut. That alone disproves your thesis. Shay's rebellion happened. You made your thesis before you got the facts. You read some slanted history and decided it was true before analyzing all points of view. Give up the ghost.

You have not established anything. You are just rolling a bunch of shit off your keyboard as fact without dates, periodical support, or citations that occurred before the Constitution was ratified breaking up the union.

The first state did not ratify the Constitution until December, 1787 and the ninth in 1788. North Carolina was an independent nation for over a year and Rhode Island for over two after the union broke up following the ratification of the Constitution. If imminent war existed how about making your citations fit the dates of history.

 

[Live_Free_Or_Die]

Hamilton never supported an income tax. He opposed the income tax by signing the Constitution, which prohibits and income tax.

That ignorant comment defies everything Hamilton argued in his brief and the history of taxation by the federal government.

It was Hamilton who argued since all taxes are derived from land and paid by individuals personal property is not property in the same sense land is.

It was Hamilton who demonstrated personal property is consumable goods and a tax on carriages is a tax on an expense.

The opposite of taxing an expense is taxing income.

It was clearly Hamilton who set precedent for defining the meaning of vague terms such as direct and indirect in economic context.

My point is that people here need to stop complaining about Hamilton, and start complaining about people today who enable the income tax.

My point is if there is any blaming to be done people ought to blame themselves.

Don't waste resources on electoral politics and a vague document. Geographically organize, replace it, and take personal responsibility to do something about it.

 

[CCTelander]

Elitist, mercantilist scumbags can have a "good side"? News to me.

 

[Galileo Galilei]

That ignorant comment defies everything Hamilton argued in his brief and the history of taxation by the federal government.

It was Hamilton who argued since all taxes are derived from land and paid by individuals personal property is not property in the same sense land is.

It was Hamilton who demonstrated personal property is consumable goods and a tax on carriages is a tax on an expense.

The opposite of taxing an expense is taxing income.

It was clearly Hamilton who set precedent for defining the meaning of vague terms such as direct and indirect in economic context.



My point is if there is any blaming to be done people ought to blame themselves.

Don't waste resources on electoral politics and a vague document. Geographically organize, replace it, and take personal responsibility to do something about it.

Hamilton never supported an income tax. He opposed the income tax. That's your problem. Deal with it.

 

[Galileo Galilei]

You have not established anything. You are just rolling a bunch of shit off your keyboard as fact without dates, periodical support, or citations that occurred before the Constitution was ratified breaking up the union.

The first state did not ratify the Constitution until December, 1787 and the ninth in 1788. North Carolina was an independent nation for over a year and Rhode Island for over two after the union broke up following the ratification of the Constitution. If imminent war existed how about making your citations fit the dates of history.

Tempest at Dawn

YouTube - Tempest at Dawn

 

[AuH20]

Hamilton never supported an income tax. He opposed the income tax by signing the Constitution, which prohibits and income tax.

This fact alone makes Hamilton small government by today's standards.

My point is that people here need to stop complaining about Hamilton, and start complaining about people today who enable the income tax.

True. Hamilton is unfairly savaged with many unsubstantiated accusations. Comparing a modern day Fabian Socialist to Alexander Hamilton is like comparing Night to Day.