MelissaWV
Member
- Joined
- Jan 4, 2008
- Messages
- 17,200
Justin...
The original statement I responded to was:
I found this to be a false statement, which I countered, providing reasons. I don't think the layoffs are less likely to affect women. The logic that fewer women being laid off means they will not be affected by them does not follow.
Your response was...
Followed by similar paragraphs.
Your later response, which you for some strange reason attribute to me via quotes, was...
I doubt your claims at least as much as I doubt your ability to read my posts and understand what I was responding to.
The fact that you said
...just goes to show you aren't reading, since AF did talk about the particular subset of women (in Government and nursing jobs) being insulated from the effects of the layoffs.
Why does one gender have to have some kind of monopoly on being screwed over by this economy? Why's that so important to you?
If I heard that stuff every day, I'd make a value judgement as to whether or not my interaction with the people saying it was worth it. Then I'd decide whether to stay or go.
More of your logical, unemotional responses:
Was this by chance a Composition class?
Seriously, though, what's the anecdote have to do with my observation that a downturn in the economy does affect everyone?
You do have one thing right, though:
No kidding. We're all getting fucked over. You're arguing as to what position it's being done in.
Yes, you're being illogical, and absolutely you are being emotional.
The original statement I responded to was:
More women than men work in stable or government jobs, less likely to be affected by layoffs.
I found this to be a false statement, which I countered, providing reasons. I don't think the layoffs are less likely to affect women. The logic that fewer women being laid off means they will not be affected by them does not follow.
Your response was...
You really think you are still at a disadvantage compared to a man? You really think men are not being hit harder by the recession than women?
Followed by similar paragraphs.
Your later response, which you for some strange reason attribute to me via quotes, was...
Its hardly a trollfest! That really annoys me. I get insulted everyday for just being a straight white male, which I didn't even decide to be. So I say what straight white men everywhere need to be saying together to get our respect back from other people, and that is somehow a "trollfest?" I gave you PERFECTLY logical points to refute. Instead of logically refuting my points, you respond with an emotional rant not addressing the points I made. If I called women stupid women everyday, and you had to hear comments like that everyday of your life, wouldn't you be bothered by it? Especially if when you said something about it people told you that you're being sexist towards men by accusing them of calling you stupid? Because that is exactly what straight white men deal with every single day.
I doubt your claims at least as much as I doubt your ability to read my posts and understand what I was responding to.
The fact that you said
Men are being hit harder. That does not mean women are not being affected.
...just goes to show you aren't reading, since AF did talk about the particular subset of women (in Government and nursing jobs) being insulated from the effects of the layoffs.
Why does one gender have to have some kind of monopoly on being screwed over by this economy? Why's that so important to you?
If I heard that stuff every day, I'd make a value judgement as to whether or not my interaction with the people saying it was worth it. Then I'd decide whether to stay or go.
More of your logical, unemotional responses:
WE HAVE HELPED ALL OF YOU AND PUSHED YOU UP ON OUR SHOULDERS AND STILL YOU DEMAND THAT YOU ALL ARE NOT EQUAL, WHEN YOU ARE NOW ABOVE US THANKS TO US QUIETLY LISTENING TO ALL THIS HATE SPEECH TOWARDS US AND THANKS TO US PUTTING UP WITH ALL THE UNFAIR INEQUALITIES DIRECTED TOWARDS US!!!!!!!
You don't see the irony in this statement, where you sound like every cliche minority that's ever boo-hooed about bad treatment by "the Man"?However, you don't walk in our shoes everyday, and don't see the world as a straight white man, so I don't think you notice the ridiculous discrimination we face all the time.
For example, I have had female professors, at least 3 of them, that gave me a lower class grade than I deserved because I was a white male, and going to get a B or A depending on what class. I am absolutely certain one professor did this because I know my grades, I talked to the professor so she knew me out of random students, and I got a C+ when I should have got an A-.
Was this by chance a Composition class?

You do have one thing right, though:
"its not just men or women, its everyone because we're all equal."
No kidding. We're all getting fucked over. You're arguing as to what position it's being done in.
Yes, you're being illogical, and absolutely you are being emotional.