You gotta look at it from a bit higher perspective. If that money is all maintained within the Fed's closed system of banks that make up the Fed Res System, the Fed never loses ownership of it, nor do the top level personnel that administer those banks go against directives from the FRB. Do remember that all of it is private currency owned by the Fed in the first place (says so right on the notes), comparable to casino chips in a casino. Reserves held with the Fed or in bank trust accounts, etc.
I agree that the Fed can delete money that it owns. But once they give it to someone they can't delete it.
But then what good is that money that the Fed creates if they have to perpetually own it? That means they can never SPEND IT. And once they spend it they can't erase it because it now belongs to someone else.
Suppose the Fed secretly creates some money and gives it to some European bank. What does the Fed say?, "Here's 10 billion, you can deposit it in your account, you can look at all the 0000s, you can fantasize about the luxury yachts you could buy with it, but YOU CAN NEVER SPEND IT! even if you are starving to death, you can even buy a loaf of bread with it!".
Think about this. Has any country ever significantly reduced it's monetary base? Japan contracted its monetary base by a few percentage points but that didn't last long. It's never been done because it's virtually impossible. It means someone has to have LESS MONEY than they had before. And most people don't volunteer for that.
Do keep in mind that my original comment you replied to was specifically about stock market 'money' that makes up the point value of the markets on any given day. Much of it is mere accounting entry digits created within bank's books that they use to trade equities back and forth between each other thus bidding up the prices. It gives an illusion of market value that isn't real.
That's a good point. That might be a case where they can delete it, since they own it. And it serves a purpose since it drives up the price. I need to think about that.
What I was referring to was the idea that we don't need to worry about inflation any more now that currency is created electronically. That somehow the money can just be erased. That won't work because by definition if the money is driving up prices, it's out in circulation and someone other than the Fed owns it. So if the Fed erased it, someone would be highly pissed off. Besides that the idea that electronic money is different than paper money is false. You can always go to your bank and exchange your electronic money for paper money.
Erasing their brokerage account contents happens like clockwork, however.
Exactly. Like I said, the primary purpose of the markets is to collect 401k/IRA/retail earned money from the people and then take it. Handing over money to a bank/brokerage means you lose any equitable title to the money and it becomes legally the property of the bank/brokerage, under trust law. In God We TRUST! That means trust law, not the sheep's definition of 'trust'. My research into this (reinhardt's Catholic Legatus info from 2008 that appears to be happening again right now) leads me to believe that the taken, earned, money is considered a tithe to the Vatican by the Catholic business people that run the companies that make up the lion's share of the markets. When the markets "correct" (crash), what is actually happening is that earned money from the people is being removed. The market bottom is the point where it's nothing but bank accounting entries left (S&P500 bottom in 2009 was '666', after all). Then they start the cycle all over again. The key take-away is that only money earned by labor/energy/blood/sweat/toil has value.
(side note: a coincidence that bankruptcy related credit reporting periods are either 7 or 10 years depending on the filing, while various market crashes also happen every 7 or 10 years? Nope, all biblical, since the economic system we live under is still ancient Roman canon law. Lloyd Blankfein did tell us that he was doing God's work, didn't he?)
Yeah, it's not so simple to just erase people's checking "account" contents. Erasing their brokerage account contents happens like clockwork, however. As for the going to the bank to receive paper notes, yes that is true....unless everyone does it at the same time. Then ya got problemsThat's a big reason they want to eventually implement fully digital blockchain based "banking". No more bank run fears and price inflation risks that arise from paper notes, among other reasons. But it also means that people become literal slaves by working for something that only exists in their minds.
My research into this (reinhardt's Catholic Legatus info from 2008 that appears to be happening again right now) leads me to believe that the taken, earned, money is considered a tithe to the Vatican by the Catholic business people that run the companies that make up the lion's share of the markets.
How many 401k's have been seized so far? How many brokerage accounts wiped out?
Reinhardt claimed that every time the Legatus group went on a pilgrimage, markets crash. The problem is that they go on pilgrimages three or four times a year and markets don't collapse three or four times a year. Yet people paid as much as $750 to get his advice (at least that is what he started charging for access to his website- how many actually paid is unknown).
Not sure what you mean. The Fed deletes private individual 401K deposits?
What do you think a market crash is??? That money you contributed goes somewhere. It doesn't just vanish into thin air.
Asset prices aren't the same thing as currency.
Huh? An asset price is the cost of the asset in a currency. I don't follow you here. You put your earned money into the market to obtain an equitable (use) title of a share of stock. That currency goes into a brokerage trust account and a "tag" is applied to a share of stock with "your" name on it. You never own the stock. The DTC always owns it, as trustee, and the digital currency is placed into a separate pooled trust account, where the trustee of that account takes ownership of the currency. That currency stays in that trust account and is used to clear transactions through the DTC. When a crash occurs, it is the assets being sold/liquidated and the pooled currency withdrawn from the trust account. It was your currency and then it's gone. It went somewhere.
Do you understand how trusts operate? It's all trusts so if not, learn about how trusts operate to understand it better. I'm not inclined to give a lecture on trust law and how it applies to the movements of currency and stocks within the system. No doubt it's a complicated system and is not easy to explain in a cliff notes version.
eta: a bit of historical context may help. Sometime ago, in the 1300's iirc, some guy in a funny hat shaped like a fish head (homage to the fish god Dagon) declared that everything in the world was his property and always will be. Funny hat guy was the Roman Emperor or the Pope or whatever he called himself back then. The trust law system was then instituted to bring this papal declaration to fruition. That same trust law system is still in effect today and is used by Vatican adherents and foot soldiers (Jesuits) to continue to enforce that declaration. The 'NWO' we hear about is quite literally the end result of the global enforcement of that declaration, making everything, legally, the property of the Vatican under trust law.
If I buy a rock for $10, that person who sold it to me got $10. I decide to sell that rock but I can only find somebody willing to pay $5 for it. Where did the $5 I lost go to?
Suppose the person who sold it to you for ten, and the person who bought it for five, are one and the same person. If you are his banker, and one fine day that extra five dollars is "simply gone" from his account, are you or are you not an embezzler?
Your implication that a falling market produces only losers and no winners is childish propaganda. Anyone who buys and/or sells is going to win or lose.
Then where did the money go?
It comes out of the pocket of the person who bought high, and goes into the pocket of the person who bought low and sold high, if any.
If there were no sales, there was no money. I can change the price tag on a piece of merchandise a dozen times. But so long as it collects dust on the shelf, it means nothing. Oh, it might affect how much the owner can borrow against the asset. But that's about it. Just because there's a dollar sign on the price tag does not mean money ever went anywhere at all.
This really isn't rocket science, Zippy. Valuation means nothing until there's a sale. And even though money is worth less daily, where money does enter into it, the number of dollars involved is a zero sum game. Every dollar someone loses speculating winds up in somebody's pocket.
So it begs the question: When you ask where the money went, are you actually talking about money? Or are you talking about valuation--price tags--and using them to spin the stock market as a magical place where no one ever gets fleeced?
The money. I bought my rock for $10 and sold it for $5. Who got the extra $5 I lost?
Suppose the person who sold it to you for ten, and the person who bought it for five, are one and the same person. If you are his banker, and one fine day that extra five dollars is "simply gone" from his account, are you or are you not an embezzler?
Your implication that a falling market produces only losers and no winners is childish propaganda. Anyone who buys and/or sells is going to win or lose.
Suppose the person who sold it to you for ten, and the person who bought it for five, are one and the same person. If you are his banker, and one fine day that extra five dollars is "simply gone" from his account, are you or are you not an embezzler?
Your implication that a falling market produces only losers and no winners is childish propaganda. Anyone who buys and/or sells is going to win or lose.
Thank you. All of the transactions go through one single entity called the DTC, the Depository Trust Company (aka DTCC and Cede&Co.), and that is where money "disappears" to. So yes the buyer and seller are ultimately the same entity, the DTC. The DTC is who keeps that $5.
They don't call it The Tower Of Power for nothing.
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED READ ABOUT HOW MARKETS REALLY OPERATE:
https://ecclesia.org/forum/uploads/bondservant/BankingScam.pdf
WHAT DOES DTCC DO?
The Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (DTCC), through its subsidiaries, provides industry-leading solutions to safeguard the world’s financial markets. For more than 40 years, we have served as the premier post-trade market infrastructure in the industry, advancing the automation, centralization, standardization and streamlining of processes critical to the markets’ safety and soundness. Today, we stand at the center of global trading activity, processing trillions of dollars of securities transactions on a daily basis. We serve as the centralized clearinghouse for more than 50 exchanges and equity platforms, maintaining multiple data and operating centers worldwide providing strong business continuity and around the-clock support. User owned and governed, DTCC serves the needs of clients from initial onboarding through trading, clearance, settlement, asset servicing and data reporting.
We provide services across multiple asset classes, including:
- Clearing
- Institutional matching
- Settlement
- Asset servicing
- Collateral management
- Global data management
- Information services
WHAT IS DTC?
The Depository Trust Company (DTC), DTCC’s central securities depository subsidiary, provides depository and book-entry services and operates a securities settlement system. In this regard, DTC holds eligible securities on behalf of Participants and its activities include transfers and pledges of securities, and the settlement of transactions for Participants by book-entry, free of payment or delivery versus payment.
DTC provides (i) settlement services for virtually all equity, corporate and municipal debt trades and Money Market Instruments in the U.S. Approximately 1.4 million settlement-related transactions per day, with a value of approximately $600 billion, are completed at DTCC in an efficient and risk-controlled process and (ii)central safekeeping and asset servicing for securities issues from 131 countries and territories valued at US$37.2 trillion. Asset services include: underwriting, corporate actions processing, securities processing, global tax services and issuer services.
What is the net worth of the DTC? If what you say is true, that must be $trillions. (they are more of a book-keeping operation which makes money charging fees for their services- they hold securities in custody but don't actually own them- like a bank is custodian for your deposits with them- they hold them for you but the money belongs to you. They act kinda like blockchain in bitcoin transactions- they keep track of all the transactions).
An audit as of December 31, 2017 shows their net assets to be $33 billion. What about the $trillions of stocks you think they own?
Revenues: $1.7 billion and expenses for the year at $1.4 billion with net profits of $165 million.
(see DTCC 2017 Financials pdf: https://www.google.com/search?rlz=1...0j0i71j0i22i30j33i160j33i22i29i30.T2D4S-1QxEo )
http://www.dtcc.com/settlement-and-asset-services/issuer-services/how-issuers-work-with-dtc
DTC brings efficiency to the securities industry by retaining custody of more than 1.3 million active securities issues valued at US$54.2 trillion as of 7/31/2017, including securities issued in the US and more than 131 countries and territories.