heavenlyboy34
Member
- Joined
- Jul 4, 2008
- Messages
- 59,093
No, your purchase isn't wrong just because it affects everyone-that is a natural fluctuation-like the old cliche about "a butterfly in japan flutters its wings and a windstorm occurs in the mid-atlantic" or however that goes. Even your very existence technically affects everyone because you use resources to survive. It's also voluntary. It actually benefits everyone because it maintains a good balance of supply/demand.(opportunity costs and the various laws of economics and nature will always exist and cannot be repealed) Political action, on the other hand (especially State action) is deliberate, stupid, involuntary and distorts the natural order of things (in a bad way). The good thing about a RP figure using political action is that he tends to wield it responsibly and rationally. So, I do think that an anarchist can vote in this case, justifying it as an act of self-defense against State predation and tyranny. Plus, at this time the vast majority of people in this (and most) society are not yet moral enough to handle true freedom.If I'm rich and I buy tons of stock in a company - the price for everyone naturally goes up. My actions have 'affected everybody' - does this mean it's illegitimate, or aggression, etc?
Glad you would vote for him at least, though. I just don't buy the argument that because it affects everyone it's some form of aggression or illegitimate or a violation of the NAP or something. I think we can all see it's relevance to the analogy above.
Voting in a poll or 'the polls' is a suggestion, it's speech, nothing more. It may be a suggestion box for slaves, but hey - Now we're back to the whole 'nice slavemaster' (who wants to free the slaves) vs the 'brutally oppressive serial rapist slavemaster'.

Last edited: