Snowball
Member
- Joined
- Nov 25, 2011
- Messages
- 5,234
Things are in a state of flux right now in both theatres. It's a crossroads for both. There is more opportunity for a cessation/freeze of hostilities in Israel than there has been since October, and the same goes for Ukraine. Here's my brief thoughts about the current situations.*
Israel/Palestine: The Biden Adm is not only putting heavy pressure on Israel to bite on the peace deal, with its three main points, including the exchange of all Israeli hostages and many Palestinian, a real ceasefire with a road to peace that goes beyond 6 weeks, if Israel is interested in that, and a rebuilding and repopulation of Gaza by Palestinians, according to a timeline at Israel's discretion with allowances for Israel's security needs and a chance for Israeli participation and global Jewish financiers and developers (international bankers) who will assist. Biden has outlined the 3-point plan, so you can easily look it up. Members of the Knesset and government agencies are actively trying to oust Netanyahu since he doesn't appear willing to work on this plan. Yair Lapid is among the most vocal, but he's also going to support Netanyahu IF Netanyahu agrees to begin working on hostage exchanges and peace talks. If not, Lapid is going to try and oust Netanyahu, which may happen. Macron backs the plan as does every major player, although the UK is in a transition stage so Rishi Sunak isn't really operating as a true PM any longer. Macron and Scholz have gone as far as to say, along with others, that the ICJ could be allowed to arrest Netanyahu and Gallant if either is in their countries. This is increasing domestic pressure against Netanyahu. Disregarding the Biden plan, Netanyahu today is still saying there can be no peace until Hamas is destroyed. Lapid totally disagrees, and has called for Smotrich (Minister of Finance) and Ben-Gvir (Minister of National Security), the two most powerful ultra-right influencers of Netanyahu (he is only PM because he formed a coalition gov with them) to leave the government. Also, there are persistent mini-battles with Hezbollah, and that's a situation Netanyahu may attempt to exploit, but unlike in months past, it's not seen as a real opportunity for him to remain in power. So, because of internal pressures and the opposition of the US, Netanyahu may not be able to launch a major offensive against Rafah. Still, he could cling to power until a bitter end, which may even involve a forcible coup to take place against him. Alternatively, if Ben-Gvir and Smotrich are tossed out by Netanyahu, he will be able to form a new coalition with the centrists and left, enough to remain PM, make a joint-session speech in the US Congress, etc. This is not a hard choice for him to make. He knows the limits of his power are increasing and that we're well past the point where he can dictate anything without center-left and American backing.*
Russia/Ukraine: Zelensky doesn't want peace in any attainable sense, and his summit (funded by US) this weekend will, of course, end in failure, because it's goals are not peace, but more war. He is not expected to remain in office much longer, but Biden has no interest in escalation in Ukraine right now, or Israel, or anywhere, as the election heats up with its demands on fundraising and electability, and even on security for the DNC convention. He has a debate with Trump scheduled later this month. Biden is eschewing the summit in favor of fundraising, which is a clear sign of a de-escalation preference by Biden and top Democrats. Putin has suggested Russia's openness to peace talks. Without the pushing of the US and the UK for escalation in Ukraine, neither Macron or anyone else is going to fill this gap. Macron doesn't even have the support of the French population or most of his own forces, who have no interest in Ukraine. The Baltics are a joke. Still, this doesn't mean that contractors won't stop assisting Ukraine in attacks, or that low-cost, measured risk operations against Russia won't take place, or that the hardliners in Ukraine of any nationality aren't working on more provocations that are highly escalatory in nature.*
Unfortunately, until Netanyahu and Zelensky are willing to bend, there can be no peace, but it's becoming clearer that they can be forced to bend, or they will be replaced. The opportunity and level of support for peace has never been higher than in the present.
If I had to wager a guess right now, I'd say Netanyahu chooses to remain, which means he can go ahead and alienate the hard-right, but replace their political support with new centrist/left backing, and remain in office.
Although chances are lower for impending peace in Ukraine, that is likely to change also in the coming weeks. The Summer Olympics in Paris, the US elections, the UK elections, increasing discontent in Ukraine, realities on the battlefield - these are going to contribute to a softening on postures that will be difficult to reverse course on. This is what Putin is hoping for, rather than wage a costly and bloody full occupation war against the remaining 80% of Ukraine. Most likely, he wil be able to avoid that. There could be isolated challenges, but the trend is towards resolution.
I expect that the cooling-off of both this summer will elevate Biden's favorability in the polls, and then he (or another Democrat) will coast to an easier-than-expected re-election in November.
Israel/Palestine: The Biden Adm is not only putting heavy pressure on Israel to bite on the peace deal, with its three main points, including the exchange of all Israeli hostages and many Palestinian, a real ceasefire with a road to peace that goes beyond 6 weeks, if Israel is interested in that, and a rebuilding and repopulation of Gaza by Palestinians, according to a timeline at Israel's discretion with allowances for Israel's security needs and a chance for Israeli participation and global Jewish financiers and developers (international bankers) who will assist. Biden has outlined the 3-point plan, so you can easily look it up. Members of the Knesset and government agencies are actively trying to oust Netanyahu since he doesn't appear willing to work on this plan. Yair Lapid is among the most vocal, but he's also going to support Netanyahu IF Netanyahu agrees to begin working on hostage exchanges and peace talks. If not, Lapid is going to try and oust Netanyahu, which may happen. Macron backs the plan as does every major player, although the UK is in a transition stage so Rishi Sunak isn't really operating as a true PM any longer. Macron and Scholz have gone as far as to say, along with others, that the ICJ could be allowed to arrest Netanyahu and Gallant if either is in their countries. This is increasing domestic pressure against Netanyahu. Disregarding the Biden plan, Netanyahu today is still saying there can be no peace until Hamas is destroyed. Lapid totally disagrees, and has called for Smotrich (Minister of Finance) and Ben-Gvir (Minister of National Security), the two most powerful ultra-right influencers of Netanyahu (he is only PM because he formed a coalition gov with them) to leave the government. Also, there are persistent mini-battles with Hezbollah, and that's a situation Netanyahu may attempt to exploit, but unlike in months past, it's not seen as a real opportunity for him to remain in power. So, because of internal pressures and the opposition of the US, Netanyahu may not be able to launch a major offensive against Rafah. Still, he could cling to power until a bitter end, which may even involve a forcible coup to take place against him. Alternatively, if Ben-Gvir and Smotrich are tossed out by Netanyahu, he will be able to form a new coalition with the centrists and left, enough to remain PM, make a joint-session speech in the US Congress, etc. This is not a hard choice for him to make. He knows the limits of his power are increasing and that we're well past the point where he can dictate anything without center-left and American backing.*
Russia/Ukraine: Zelensky doesn't want peace in any attainable sense, and his summit (funded by US) this weekend will, of course, end in failure, because it's goals are not peace, but more war. He is not expected to remain in office much longer, but Biden has no interest in escalation in Ukraine right now, or Israel, or anywhere, as the election heats up with its demands on fundraising and electability, and even on security for the DNC convention. He has a debate with Trump scheduled later this month. Biden is eschewing the summit in favor of fundraising, which is a clear sign of a de-escalation preference by Biden and top Democrats. Putin has suggested Russia's openness to peace talks. Without the pushing of the US and the UK for escalation in Ukraine, neither Macron or anyone else is going to fill this gap. Macron doesn't even have the support of the French population or most of his own forces, who have no interest in Ukraine. The Baltics are a joke. Still, this doesn't mean that contractors won't stop assisting Ukraine in attacks, or that low-cost, measured risk operations against Russia won't take place, or that the hardliners in Ukraine of any nationality aren't working on more provocations that are highly escalatory in nature.*
Unfortunately, until Netanyahu and Zelensky are willing to bend, there can be no peace, but it's becoming clearer that they can be forced to bend, or they will be replaced. The opportunity and level of support for peace has never been higher than in the present.
If I had to wager a guess right now, I'd say Netanyahu chooses to remain, which means he can go ahead and alienate the hard-right, but replace their political support with new centrist/left backing, and remain in office.
Although chances are lower for impending peace in Ukraine, that is likely to change also in the coming weeks. The Summer Olympics in Paris, the US elections, the UK elections, increasing discontent in Ukraine, realities on the battlefield - these are going to contribute to a softening on postures that will be difficult to reverse course on. This is what Putin is hoping for, rather than wage a costly and bloody full occupation war against the remaining 80% of Ukraine. Most likely, he wil be able to avoid that. There could be isolated challenges, but the trend is towards resolution.
I expect that the cooling-off of both this summer will elevate Biden's favorability in the polls, and then he (or another Democrat) will coast to an easier-than-expected re-election in November.