Gold Standard and the Great Depression

Joined
Jul 8, 2007
Messages
3,283
Please respond to the following so that I can counter this argument:

"If declines in the money supply induced by adherence to the gold standard were a principal reason for economic depression, then countries leaving gold earlier should have been able to avoid the worst of the Depression and begin an earlier process of recovery. The evidence strongly supports this implication.

For example, Great Britain and Scandinavia, which left the gold standard in 1931, recovered much earlier than France and Belgium, which stubbornly remained on gold. As Friedman and Schwartz noted in their book, countries such as China--which used a silver standard rather than a gold standard--avoided the Depression almost entirely.

The finding that the time at which a country left the gold standard is the key determinant of the severity of its depression and the timing of its recovery has been shown to hold for literally dozens of countries, including developing countries. This intriguing result not only provides additional evidence for the importance of monetary factors in the Depression, it also explains why the timing of recovery from the Depression differed across countries.
 
As they said on" Laugh In ", Very interesting

I believe the GREAT DEPRESSION was caused by a big part with people buying stocks with a 10% margin.

It was a hugh ponsi scheme, when the big players started selling , stocks started snowballing, every one was getting margin calls which they couldn't make , so they were sold out , this caused more selling . People just ran out of money and couldn't buy anything, things just feed on its self.

I agree that the gold standard stopped countries from inflating their way out of it like Germany.

The depression would have still happened.
 
As they said on" Laugh In ", Very interesting

I believe the GREAT DEPRESSION was caused by a big part with people buying stocks with a 10% margin.

It was a hugh ponsi scheme, when the big players started selling , stocks started snowballing, every one was getting margin calls which they couldn't make , so they were sold out , this caused more selling . People just ran out of money and couldn't buy anything, things just feed on its self.

I agree that the gold standard stopped countries from inflating their way out of it like Germany.

The depression would have still happened.

No. The Great Depression was caused by what Hoover and Roosevelt did AFTER the stock market crash of '29.
 
This argument is not suggesting that the gold standard caused the Great Depression, but rather that it prevents a nation from rapidly getting out of said depression
 
I agree with Peter Schiff , Roosevelt prolonged the depression. I think the mkt crash starter it.

The stock market crash created a recession. Hoover made it into a depression. Roosevelt made it into a prolong depression.
 
This argument is not suggesting that the gold standard caused the Great Depression, but rather that it prevents a nation from rapidly getting out of said depression

Inflating another buble by devaluating the currency is not what I consider "gettig out of a depression". Its just posponing it, as USA is about to discover in this and next years.
 
The stock market crash created a recession. Hoover made it into a depression. Roosevelt made it into a prolong depression.

Obviously the guy with Lewrockwell.com and Mises.org in his signature offers a clear, and in my view perfect, summation of events. :)
 
Back
Top