Gold is no solution

So, if other people want to use Gold as currency, you don't think the state should interfere with them?

:) , I am a tight wad , so I should need nothing that costs more than an ounce of copper or a silver dime. Gold is for big spenders :) ,my main man Cubical can by an estate , lol , I already have one and do not like the property taxes.
 
That is usually done on paper. Paper gold is much easier to manipulate.

There is no reason to need more of it. Just make each ounce worth more and people wouldn't have to carry around as much of it.

Paper has been printed by sovereigns too.... but I'll take the gold over the paper any day.

Just like paper can be printed. It's just that people will find a way to cheat if they can.

Don't need a gold based system. We need a system of just weights and measures and the people decide how much a certain weight in metal is worth.

I agree Doc.
 
If the govt hadn't attacked e-gold and liberty dollar they would both probably be pretty huge by now, with probably a competitior or two nipping at their heels. The Federal reserve would be on its way to obsolescence and worldwide wealth would be increasing at a much more consistent and higher rate without the leeches of govt siphoning off wealth.
 
Gold's small quantities make booms and busts even easier to engineer.
There is only about 9 trillion dollars worth of gold the price would have to double or triple for there to be nearly enough of it.
Gold is not inherently free market money either it has often been minted by sovereigns and government. To the small extent we have a market in currency people use hours based systems which are paper money or they use virtual currencies like bitcoin.
Gold itself can still be manipulated through tungsten and coin clipping.
Fractional Reserve Banking is still possible under a gold based system the practice was invented under one.


There is no shortage of gold

http://www.thegoldstandardnow.org/t...-enough-gold-to-operate-a-gold-standard-today
 
FYI to all, pathtofreedom is a georgist or geoist. His avatar is of henry george. My guess is, this thread will lead to lvt eventually.
 
FYI to all, pathtofreedom is a georgist or geoist. His avatar is of henry george. My guess is, this thread will lead to lvt eventually.
Why would it lead to LVT? This thread is specifically about the issue of Gold.
 
Last edited:
If banks are just going to be operating under fractional reserve banking what is the point of gold?
 
Gold's small quantities make booms and busts even easier to engineer.
There is only about 9 trillion dollars worth of gold the price would have to double or triple for there to be nearly enough of it.
Gold is not inherently free market money either it has often been minted by sovereigns and government. To the small extent we have a market in currency people use hours based systems which are paper money or they use virtual currencies like bitcoin.
Gold itself can still be manipulated through tungsten and coin clipping.
Fractional Reserve Banking is still possible under a gold based system the practice was invented under one.

And you don't have a clue.

Myth 1: There isn’t Enough Gold to Operate a Gold Standard Today

http://www.thegoldstandardnow.org/g...-enough-gold-to-operate-a-gold-standard-today

Myth 9: A Gold Standard is Vulnerable to Speculative Attacks

http://www.thegoldstandardnow.org/g...standard-is-vulnerable-to-speculative-attacks
 
If banks are just going to be operating under fractional reserve banking what is the point of gold?

The money can only expand so much under a gold standard w/ fractional reserve banking. Under fiat it can expand indefinitely.
 
The money can only expand so much under a gold standard w/ fractional reserve banking. Under fiat it can expand indefinitely.
Complete nonsense money can expand just as much under gold with fractional reserve as it can today. In fractional reserve banking money is created. The majority of money some 90% is created by commercial banks.
 
Complete nonsense money can expand just as much under gold with fractional reserve as it can today. In fractional reserve banking money is created. The majority of money some 90% is created by commercial banks.

No, its not nonsense. You don't understand how FRACTIONAL reserve banking works, obviously.

It can only expand to a multiplier of the money supply. There is a LIMIT to what it can expand to. With fiat there is no limit.

We had fractional reserve banking under the gold standard and there was no huge loss of the money's value over 100 years like there has been from 1913-today.

Just take a look a graph of the value of the dollar. You'll notice it starts to drop massively after the end of the gold standard.
 
Last edited:
Because banks offer bills of credit based on something tangible under a hard money standard.

Right now they offer credit based on...fiat government credit. It's a positive feedback loop of debt over debt over debt. When the crashes come the same feed back loop occurs but in reverse. Huge swaths of credit are destroyed as the system desperately seeks strong COLLATERAL.

When their core capital reserves deplete to the point of danger, depositors keep the bank honest by pulling their cash and rendering the bank insolvent (under a hard money standard where the government is not insuring debt over debt over debt deposits).

Hard money standards keep the over extensions at bay. The runs on banks happen far sooner than under a fiat standard. The misallocation of capital is discovered substantially sooner, thus the harm is limited because banks are constrained to servant, rather than government backed master.

If banks are just going to be operating under fractional reserve banking what is the point of gold?
 
Last edited:
If banks are just going to be operating under fractional reserve banking what is the point of gold?

I happen to think fractional reserve banking is fraud and should be treated as such. But even if you allow fractional reserve banking, the banks are limited in what they can do by the fear of bank runs. With no Fed and no fiat, they are at risk if they play their fractional reserve game. Additionally, with a free market in currency, you CHOOSE. If you don't want to take bank notes, because you are concerned about bank solvency, you don't. If you stick with gold itself or notes from trusted institutions with 100% gold backing of their notes, you will be fine.
 
Back
Top