First GOP Congressman apologizes for voting for Patriot Act

tsai3904

Member
Joined
May 13, 2010
Messages
9,397
Rep. John Culberson (TX-7)

Restoring Individual Liberty and Privacy

It looks like everyone who warned me about the Patriot Act was right - we have all been systematically lied to. It is as though we live in a totalitarian police state, and I will do everything in my power to undo the damage done to our privacy, our liberty, and our Republic. As the Declaration of Independence states, "whenever any form of government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or abolish it..."

I intend to start by filing legislation to start systematically shutting down the federal government by restoring the 10th Amendment powers of the States and restoring absolute individual liberty and privacy. I will begin with shutting down the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and strictly limiting its mission to securing our borders and ports of entry and tracking, detaining, and deporting foreign nationals. I will also figure out how to repeal and/or roll back the Patriot Act to restore the absolute right to privacy that every law abiding American citizen is supposed to enjoy.

DHS should focus on its core mission and leave police powers and protecting lives and property to individual Americans under the Second Amendment and local sheriffs and the States under the Tenth Amendment. We should follow Israel's model for homeland security by focusing on behavior and people rather than focusing on objects. This is not complicated. Political correctness needs to be tossed out in favor of common sense law enforcement techniques and an absolute guarantee of privacy for law abiding American citizens.

I regret that I voted to create the Department of Homeland Security and I regret that I voted for the Patriot Act. I never saw evidence of abuse of our privacy because Congress was lied to just as the public has been lied to. I will work hard to undo the damage these laws have done to our liberty, our privacy, and our Republic. I will be a zealot on restoring our liberty and shutting down as much of the federal police state as I can.

http://culbersonforms.house.gov/news/email/show.aspx?ID=PH6T4LWSPLEOTAFO2B36QCVTOY

Press release:
http://culberson.house.gov/restoring-individual-liberty-and-privacy/

July 24 Update: Rep. Culberson voted against the Amash Amendment that would have limited the NSA collection of everyone's phone records.

July 25 Update: Rep. Culberson doubles down and writes this "Why the Amash Amendment Wouldn’t Have Protected You".
 
Last edited:
Sounds sincere. I know he might not be, but he sounds like it. If he really does turn around, he should be forgiven.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cap
I intend to start by filing legislation to start systematically shutting down the federal government by restoring the 10th Amendment powers of the States and restoring absolute individual liberty and privacy.

Pardon?
 
So just an apology, and they're fine. They need to change jobs. That was 12 years ago. What ELSE have they done. They only apologize for this. Come on gang.

Opps, got caught *shrugs* sorry. : )
 
It looks like everyone who warned me about the Patriot Act was right - we have all been systematically lied to.

at least he's not all, "but no one could have know this would have happened!"
 
IF he's sincere, then he needs to have support from us, he'll need all the help he can get.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cap
It doesn't matter if he's sincere. To the extent that he serves our interests, we should work with him.

If he sponsors a bill to eliminate DHS, then we should rally support behind that.

If he's sincere, then great. If not, then it's just calling his bluff.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cap

It sounds really great. Right now there is a huge uproar going on over this and you're going to see a lot more of them coming forward like this. As long as the decibels stay up we're going to keep hearing this. What he SAYS sounds great, let's watch what he DOES.
 
It doesn't matter if he's sincere. To the extent that he serves our interests, we should work with him.

If he sponsors a bill to eliminate DHS, then we should rally support behind that.

If he's sincere, then great. If not, then it's just calling his bluff.

Not to mention...

I'm not apologizing for what he did. I'm not even saying that, if we actually got to the point of a Walter Blockean Nuremberg Trial, that he should necessarily get off just because he turned around (Personally, I think I'd vote to let someone like this, if he really were sincere, off but that's just me). That, however, is fantasy, we're never going to get all the way to minarchy or anarchy, so we need to work with what we've got.

IF this guy is sincere, he should absolutely not give up his position. I'm not saying we should believe him right away, but if he really is sincere, he should fight for liberty right where he is. To turn tails and run because of his bad choices in the past would be the WORST thing he could do.
 
How exactly does one "dismantle" something by merely altering it's mission?
By rethinking what the proper role of government ought to be, we as a nation would find that 95% of today's fed gov is simply not needed. From there, shuttering those agencies would be dismantling the current for of our fed gov.
 
Technically it was poorly worded, but technically I wouldn't "Dismantle" the Federal government either if I could actually control it. I'd just limit it to defense of the country and that's it. But cutting it by 90% is all but "Dismantling" it. A poor choice of words, but not a dealbreaker.
 
Back
Top