PursuePeace
Member
- Joined
- Oct 9, 2011
- Messages
- 2,493
Just watched the video.
Unfortunately, fear is a popular (and powerful) marketing tool.
Unfortunately, fear is a popular (and powerful) marketing tool.
That is quite the given. There you guys go again; putting limitations on God's power and will.
One particular framework from your particular pov and understanding.What you speak of is a "Blind" faith in some random Idea of God. Where there is no logic or reason to it, its just like believing in the tooth fairy. However, That is not what Christianity is, Christianity is not a blind faith. Christianity comes with a framework that God presents.
Two contradictions both cannot be right as scripture tells us in
Matthew 6:24 "No one can serve two masters. Either he will hate the one and love the other, or he will be devoted to the one and despise the other."
See, I'd phrase it: Can an all-powerful God make an incorrect statement, correct? I say that he can, you say that God doesn't have that power.What you argue is a straw man argument, kind of like saying “can God Tell a lie”?
Do you realize that every religion claims exclusivity and warn against "false gods." You still haven't proven that yours is the correct path or differentiate yours from any other religion. Do you think that Jesus was the only one to come down an do miracles? How can you be so sure of the workings of God? He does what he pleases. Mohammad said he was the third and final seal. Why should I believe Jesus over him? What about Joseph Smith Jr. and the LDS? Even the Christians can't even determine who is right and who is wrong from just one prophet and you claim to know God because of a book as if you can contain his workings of mere pages.
One particular framework from your particular pov and understanding.
If that is what you want to believe that says, then by all means you can have that belief. I see nothing to do with contradictions in that. This just strenghtens my point. you get from your framework what you personally want to get out of it. It doesn't mean you are right and others are wrong if they take something completely different from it. You can both be right.
See, I'd phrase it: Can an all-powerful God make an incorrect statement, correct? I say that he can, you say that God doesn't have that power.
If an all-powerful God wanted to change reality for everysingle one of us, he could. If he wanted to make your religious beliefs true, and at the same time make yieu's religious beliefs true, he could. Either that or he is not all-powerful.
Always to the negative with you. My position would be more akin to "all religions are true" than "all religions are false". But I'm an optimist who thinks that if there is an all-powerful God he could do whatever he wants even if it is beyond my own realm of understanding.No Sir. What you are arguing about are abstract points. You speak in Generic terms and never get specific. Its like the kid who makes the proclamation that “All religion is false". Yet, will never actually give any detail on what is False in each and every major religion.
...
Again at the end of it you got to get a bit more specific. If you cant get any more specific, then id tell ya to just claim "all religions are false" and rest your case.
I dont see how defending the truth is belittling the spark of the ultimate Love in their fellow man.
Your religion is about the same and small difference than other ones. You think that there is only one god as do I but you do not believe that the same god cannot come down at his own will to save humanity in other forms but not be the same gods. This is why I do not follow Christ because you put limitations on the power of God and pervert his teachings. Anywho I usually don't like getting drawn into stupid topics like this. You can't prove your right and I can't prove mine so lets let it be. Just don't go bashing anyone's religion with asinine articles like this.
Always to the negative with you. My position would be more akin to "all religions are true" than "all religions are false". But I'm an optimist who thinks that if there is an all-powerful God he could do whatever he wants even if it is beyond my own realm of understanding.
edit: I for one, would never claim "all religions are false" as that would be the height of arrogance. Of course I would never take it upon myself to declare that anybody's religion is false.
I don't know what you think I'm not being specific about. Is God All-powerful?Its not about being positive or negative. Its about you making general claims that are not centered in anything in particular apart from your own opinions. If you were to get a bit more specific, i feel that the discussion could go in a more fruitful direction. But if you continue to make general statements then we are going round and round in circles.
They are only contradictions in your reality. The contradiction you keep posting about eg: #330 is so easy to negate that I can only imagine you aren't open to other possibilities.Also to from a logical standpoint. To claim "all religions are true" is equally as arrogant as claiming "all religions are false". Claiming all is true requires the same amount of critical thinking (if not more) in order to smooth over the giant contradictions that each of the major religions presents.
Unless it is just your understanding that is contradictory.To believe that God continuously Contradicts himself over n over n over again. Is a massive burden to clear.
And the logical fallacy in your stance is simple. Why would "God" come down and say "he is the only way and everyone apart from him is false". But then keep manifesting himself over n over but each time claiming that the one before him or after him is false.
If i am to follow your logic. THe conclusion i would come to is that "God" is a giant liar and has the memory span of a baby. Because he cant seem remember claiming that he was the "ONLY" way.
In that case i guess the question ill ask you is "What is spirituality"?
My understanding of what Jesus taught comes from the Gospels. Where does your understanding on the matter come from?
My understanding of our Creator comes to me best by my own position as a parent. I have 8 children, one of which is very headstrong, defiant and not too pleasant to be around. For seven of my children my relationship and approach is very similar. As an earthly parent I attempted to force the difficult child to work within a structure that the other seven children were quite capable and successful at working within. Well because of the eighth childs personal quirks it caused an enormous amount of suffering for all parties. So I reassessed my manner of dealing with her. I deal with her differently but my expectations are still the same. We have a relationship with each other and relate to each other but through a different manner than I do with the other seven of my children. I know my child best when it comes down to it and approach her and can 'read' her better than anyone else and I am an earthly parent. How much more should we give room to the Creator to His relationship with His children?
When people get all caught up in defending their religious traditions that they are demanding another walk their path or they are not truly experiencing a relationship with their Creator, I believe it disrespects the right of the Father to come to His children in the manner He sees fit as He knows the heart of His children best. Ultimately it is that each person embrace Love as the beginning and ending of all things. By focusing one's energy on defending religion, the Love that is inside one's fellow man is not being fanned but dampered because the ill will is growing rather than what both parties share, the knowledge of a parent of ultimate Love. Therefore if I believe that the love one holds inside them is the Light of the soul, or Divine Spark, which draws them closer to God (in a like attracts like manner) by diminishing another persons walk I am belittling the spark of Ultimate Love.
I think this is why the Orthodox give a clause that they will not completely dismiss that there are those outside of the Orthodox religion who are not damned while not worshipping in the manner which they feel is the ideal means to approach Him. Pretty wise position in my opinion as to do otherwise means that He is then definable and limited.
My understanding comes from a nonreligious practice of a certain martial art that does mostly meditation, personal experience, the Bible, various Sutra, and my studies in Yoga. The truth is that breathing, yoga, and meditation are all well documented for their health benefits. When I started meditating I started sleeping less, my digestive system became more regular, I had more energy, my sinuses cleared up, I started driving slower, and I became aware of the greater world around us. I have no doubts in what I experienced, but I am was raised Christian and am not willing to dismiss these beliefs so in my mind I have reconciled Christianity to what I'll call Yoga. I can't believe that a demon improving my health and temperament. By their fruit you shall know them, and the mediators I've had dealings with have in my experience been more like Jesus than many in the Christian Church. I conclude that Yoga works because that is God's Will. I conclude that the Christian Church might have gone astray from what God wanted for us if we have to tell people that Yoga is the devil and if you practice yoga then you are going to hell.
I just try to think critically about the world and not be indoctrinated by the most common interpretations. Take the Holy Spirit. We use the word "spirit" but the word literally translates into breath. So my interpretation of Yoga can be described as submitting to God and communing with the Holy Spirit. Jesus said, "I am the way, the truth, and the life." Okay, but what does that really mean? If he says he is the life does that mean? If Jesus is the life and we are alive then doesn't that mean that we have a little part of Jesus in all of us. Maybe letting Jesus into your heart doesn't just mean saying a prayer in church, get a free ticket to heaven. Maybe our interpretation is wrong? What if the "eastern mystics" believe that meditation is closely related to your life(Jesus)-force. What if Jesus, the Life, can only be reached through spirituality?
Spirituality means submitting, forgetting about your self, and listening to the voice of God, and then trying to do God's will. How is God going to speak to you if you never listen? If you give up doing what you want and instead pray and sit quietly contemplating God's Love, then according to my interpretation you are doing Yoga.
I find it funny people with your attitude. You want to believe in an all-powerful God that can by definition do anything it wants; yet want to constrain God to your own pitiful human thinking within the bounds of earthly logic.
If an all-powerful God wanted to make 2+2=4 and at the exact same time make 2+2=5, he could. Stop thinking so limitedly.
Anything that worships a false god is demonic.
Thats only if your narrow minded religion is correct, which it isn't.
According to the Scriptures, Oh wait i forgot you reject scriptures. Yet claim to be a Christian.
Which is why i asked. Which Christ do you represent? the Christ of the scriptures or some other Christ.