BEWARE: "Shoulder Tap" Entrapment Operations at the Liquor Store

presence

Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2011
Messages
19,330
http://www.arcataeye.com/2013/03/inside-an-apdabc-shoulder-tap-operation/

ARCATA – As part of its continuing efforts to keep alcohol out of underage hands, Arcata Police ran a “shoulder tap” operation on both ends of town Friday night.


“Shoulder tap” is shorthand for teenagers hanging out in front of retail businesses that sell alcohol and asking adult patrons entering the establishment to buy booze for them. Undercover officers wait nearby on foot and in vehicles, ready to pounce when a grown-up exercises misdemeanor bad judgment. In just a few hours, six such subjects were cited and arrested, and will probably think twice about committing such a maneuver again.


Friday’s operation got underway in APD’s briefing room, where four teens – three boys and a girl, three age 17 and one 16 – were briefed on the night’s operation. The young volunteers are all part of the Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office “Police Explorer” program.


Sgt. Keith Altizer outlined the operation, which involved two teams consisting of two officers and two teens each. One team would work “north beat” – everything north of 14th Street, while the other focused on central Arcata.


Adding a festive note to the evening’s activities, it was “Shoulder Tap Day,” with dozens of law enforcement agencies across the state performing similar operations (see bottom of page).


The teens were instructed to make it clear to passersby that they are under 21 and looking for someone to buy alcohol for them. They might say they are going to a St. Patrick’s Day party, and can even offer assurances that they won’t be driving. But they can’t try to persuade the potential buyer.


The pitch will ring true if the youth asks for a specific brand of booze. Budweiser is said to meet the refined tastes of today’s party-time teen.


Most adults turn down the teen’s request, period.
Others refuse to take the money, but go in and buy alcohol on their own and then hand it to the teen on the way out.

Still others accept the money, then go in and buy booze for themselves and try to leave. They get arrested for petty theft.
It’s not uncommon for an adult to offer to sell the kids cannabis.


Altizer says that there isn’t any stereotypical booze-enabler. They come in all ages – even underaged.
Teens with fake IDs will sometimes buy liquor for the shoulder tappers.

They do have one thing in common though – their response to being arrested.
“Usually the first thing they say is, ‘Oh, that was stupid. I never do that,’” Altizer said.

In criminal law,
entrapment is conduct by a law enforcement agent
inducing a person to commit an offense
that the person would
otherwise have been unlikely to commit.[SUP]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entrapment#cite_note-1[/SUP]
In many jurisdictions, entrapment is a possible defense against criminal liability.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entrapment
The penalty for furnishing alcohol to a minor is a minimum $1,000 fine and 24 hours of community service.


If an adult agrees to make a booze buy, the shoulder-tapping teens are to raise their hoods over their heads to signal the officers. If things get “hinky” – yes, Adam-12 fans, police really do use that term – they are to raise their hands in the air, and officers will immediately intervene.


“Cops will have eyes on you the whole time,” Altizer assures the kids. “Your safety is our priority.”


We leave in an unmarked but blatantly obvious cop car, a battered Crown Victoria with antennae and a small light bar. That everyone inside is wearing hoodies doesn’t help. On the way out of the APD parking lot, Downtown Officer Chris Wilson rolls up on his bike and remarks, “You guys look like cops trying not to look like cops.”


The first stop for the south beat team is Arcata Liquors. Two lads hang out on the H Street side, making their pitch to random adults. None appear interested; it’s late afternoon, and folks are en route to other destinations for their Friday night fun. One guy in a camouflage jacket almost bites, but walks off, advising as he leaves that “Fourth Street Market doesn’t check ID’s.”


It does. “I haven’t busted them in two years,” says Officer Richard Bergstresser. But tonight’s operation doesn’t include minor decoys trying to buy liquor from stores, just the shoulder tap to patrons. So it’s off to Fourth Street.


There, the two lads mill about by the dumpsters, but foot traffic is minimal. Meanwhile out in Valley West, the other team is having all the excitement. A man at Ray’s Food Place took the teens’ money, went in and bought alcohol, then went out the other door. He is arrested on a warrant.


Lacking law enforcement action, South Team has to amuse itself with low-level kibitzing between Altizer, a San Diego Padres fan, and Bergstresser, a San Francisco Giants loyalist.


With two dry holes so far, our team heads over to the Uniontown Shopping Center, which is bound to be buzzing with people on an early Friday evening.


Altizer waits in the car as Bergstresser takes a position by the teenagers outside CVS Pharmacy. Soon a man responds to their overtures, but directs themto another guy. This other man asks twice if they are police and twice is told no. He takes their $5 bill and slips into the variety store, emerging with a 24 oz. Budweiser.


On handing it to the teens, he demands and receives a $1 fee for his trouble and is quickly detained by Bergstresser. The man, identified as James Burke, hands the officer his ID, then sits on the sidewalk next to the Freedom Shrine and graffitied newspaper racks.


Burke bolts.



As the officer calls in Burke’s particulars, the suspect clambers to his feet, lingers for a moment and then bolts away, running. Bergstresser gives chase westbound toward F Street, dropping his cell phone and citation book. He tackles the man around the corner from the shopping center, cuffs him and marches him back to the store. Altizer comes around, and soon two marked APD units are on scene.


A search turns up a cell phone charger Burke had apparently stuffed down his pants when he bought the beer. While petty theft is a misdemeanor, possession of stolen property is a felony. As it turns out, Burke is a wanted parolee who has fled from supervised probation following a previous conviction for – that’s right – possession of stolen property.
Burke busted.



Burke last made Arcata headlines during a bungled burglary attempt at HealthSPORT on May 11, 2012.


Back at the station, the cops do paperwork on the arrest as the boys talk over details of the incident. “I felt proud but sad at the same time,” says one boy of his role in the caper. “We’re happy that we caught someone, but we feel bad for him.”


The shiny can of Bud is photographed for evidence, and Altizer takes it and heads out the conference room door. What will become of the guzzleable but contraband King of Beers? “It gets poured down the drain,” he says. This draws a rueful “awwww” from teens and reporter alike, just because of the waste of a perfectly good, if cheap and mass-produced beverage. “In the old days, it would have been booked into evidence in an officer’s stomach,” Altizer admits.
Bergstresser sports a bright red patch of missing skin on his right elbow and another on his knee. He’s done for the night. “I’ll take a scratch to get a felon off the streets any time,” he says.


He turns over his duties to Wilson, who dons the requisite hoodie. Meanwhile, the Valley West team has made their second collar, citing another booze buyer.


With more than an hour to go, there’s time for one more shoulder tap, but the Plaza is off-limits because Wilson is so well known among the Plazarati.


So it’s back to Fourth Street. Within minutes, a man on a bike with a trailer agrees to buy the two teens alcohol, and he too charges a dollar for his trouble. He sings as he leaves the store with another Bud tall boy, and is rapidly detained outside.


As he is cited, passersby observe the scene and marvel at a reporter’s ability to photograph the scene without officer interference, unaware that the ride-along was pre-arranged. They’ve read about North Coast Journal Editor Carrie Peyton Dahlberg’s tense encounter with Eureka Police Officer Drake Goodale, a former APD officer, and have various opinions about the matter.


They have mixed feelings about the Shoulder Tap operation, too, with regard to possible entrapment. But in 1994, the California Supreme Court ruled unanimously that use of underage decoys is a valid tool for law enforcement to ensure that licensees are complying with the law.


But this alcohol buyer, identified as Travis Russell, gets off easy, with just a citation. He has a 215 card, so his prescription bottle of pot isn’t an issue.


Travis Russell assumes the position as Altizer and Wilson search his person.



In the remaining half-hour, there’s time for one more shoulder tap effort out at Murphy’s Sunny Brae Market. But to no avail. None of the college students are interested. They’re entirely focused on obtaining their weekend fare of beer and ice cream. The refusals are fine with Altizer and Wilson, who sense that publicity following recent similar operations may have helped reduce teen alcohol enabling.


The deposed (and disposed of) King of Beers.



By 9 p.m., it’s all over. The state ABC wants all the arrest figures sent in for its press release the next day.


• Zachariah Smithers, 33, of McKinleyville
• Jon Jimenez, 23, Cardiff
• Ludwig Dannhausen, 62, of San Diego
• Jonathan Smart, 34, of Willow Creek
• James Burke, 40, of Galt (additionally arrested on a warrant, resisting arrest and possession of stolen property)
• Travis Russell, 30, of Arcata


According to APD, statistics show that young people under the age of 21 have a higher rate of drunken driving fatalities than the general adult population.
Minor Decoy operations have been conducted by local law enforcement throughout the state since the 1980s. When the program first began, the violation rate of retail establishments selling to minors was as high as 40 to 50 percent. When conducted on a routine basis, the rate has dropped in some cities as low as 10 percent or even below.
This project is part of the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control’s Minor Decoy/Shoulder Tap Grant Project, funded by the California Office of Traffic Safety through the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.


ABC Press Release


CALIFORNIA – Agents from the California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) and Officers from the Modesto and Ontario Police Departments joined forces with more than 100 law enforcement agencies in a record-setting Decoy Shoulder Tap Operation in California Friday, March 15. The operation was conducted statewide for the second time ever.


The task force operation resulted in 475 arrests. The arrest total shattered last year’s record operation that concluded with 435 arrests.


More than 400 individuals were cited for furnishing alcoholic beverages to minors, and at least 50 were arrested for other crimes such as illegal drugs, illegal gun possession, public drunkenness, parole violations and outstanding warrants.


ABC agents and local law enforcement conducted a program called a Decoy Shoulder Tap Operation, which can lead to the arrest of adults who purchase alcohol for people under 21 years old.


Under the program, a minor under the direct supervision of a peace officer will stand outside a liquor or convenience store and ask patrons to buy them alcohol.
The minor indicates in some way he or she is underage and cannot purchase the alcohol.


If the adults agree to purchase alcohol for the minor, officers then arrest and cite them for furnishing alcohol to the minor. The penalty for furnishing alcohol to a minor is a minimum $1,000 fine and 24 hours of community service.


The program is intended to reduce the availability of alcohol to minors. According to the American Medical Association, underage drinking can increase chances of risky sexual behavior and teen pregnancy, juvenile delinquency, compromise health and result in unintentional injury and death.
 
This reminds me of the time I was approached by two kids wanting to buy alcohol. Thing is - is that there were two guys in workout jumpers waiting and watching in a white van.

My friends ended up buying it for them anyways, and placed it a half block down the road.
 
LOL I'd be like "Hey kid, why don't you smoke pot instead, it's better for you and you don't need my help to get it."
 
Or tell them to make their own beer. It will only take you a week and will probably be a lot better than budweiser.

LOL I'd be like "Hey kid, why don't you smoke pot instead, it's better for you and you don't need my help to get it."
 
It isn't entrapment unless they beg or offer money. But they are targeting the wrong people. They should go after the store owners.

I actually participated in a program similar to this when I was 17. We only targeted establishments. There were very strict rules as well. As I stated before, you couldn't beg or offer money. If they asked you how old you are, your birth date, or for your drivers license you did have to provide them with accurate information. About 75% of the stores I busted actually asked for my ID but still sold it anyway. Twice was I offered by someone, that was in the store, to buy the alcohol for me when my ID was turned down, outside. I gave both of them like three opportunities not to do it but they insisted.

The only reason our state participates in programs like this is to continue to receive federal funding. At least that is what the agents told me.
 
The only reason our state participates in programs like this is to continue to receive federal funding. At least that is what the agents told me.

I imagine they also like to ruin people's lives in court, and fines and shut down small businesses. Too bad it's not 18+ anymore like in my parents days.
 
It isn't entrapment unless they beg or offer money. But they are targeting the wrong people. They should go after the store owners.

I actually participated in a program similar to this when I was 17. We only targeted establishments. There were very strict rules as well. As I stated before, you couldn't beg or offer money. If they asked you how old you are, your birth date, or for your drivers license you did have to provide them with accurate information. About 75% of the stores I busted actually asked for my ID but still sold it anyway. Twice was I offered by someone, that was in the store, to buy the alcohol for me when my ID was turned down, outside. I gave both of them like three opportunities not to do it but they insisted.

The only reason our state participates in programs like this is to continue to receive federal funding. At least that is what the agents told me.

Did the cops pay you?
 
I imagine they also like to ruin people's lives in court, and fines and shut down small businesses. Too bad it's not 18+ anymore like in my parents days.

Here they would give them a chance even after they busted them. First time offenders got the fine reduced from like $1600 to $200. After the third time SLED would be notified and then the store could have their alcohol license revoked. SLED even gives back their alcohol license after 6 months.

This is the best way to address the issue and I don't find it unconstitutional in anyway. As long as their are rules just like the ones that they outlined to me. But all of the blame is placed on the individual that actually sold the alcohol until the store is busted several times.

Did the cops pay you?
Yes

They never placed anyone under arrest either.
 
Last edited:
I imagine they also like to ruin people's lives in court, and fines and shut down small businesses. Too bad it's not 18+ anymore like in my parents days.

Depends on the state. I know for sure in at least 2 states, but I think most, that you can sell beer to 18+ if it's 3.2% but only from grocery stores and convenience stores. and it's like 6% for beer from a liquor store. Thing is, one is ETOH content by weight and the other by volume, so the alcohol % is actually almost identical. It's just BS regulations/laws.

OK - no more, looks like only 3-4 states or territories where that is the case now.

Looks like mid-late 80's for most of the country:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._history_of_alcohol_minimum_purchase_age_by_state

"Kept at 18
despite 10% highway funding
penalty under Drinking Age Act."

I Think it's TX that told the feds to go fuck themselves and raised their highway speed limit. Odd that they didn't buck everything else under fed highway funds blackmail at the same time.

National Minimum Drinking Age Act:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Minimum_Drinking_Age_Act_of_1984

This is what happens when you let the federal gvmt collect taxes, much of which is wasted "administering the program" and giving a little bit of it back to the states. WITH STRINGS ATTACHED! Now that the fud guv is shorting states, this could start breaking down. Highway funding is commonly used - hwy speed limit, seat belt and helmet laws, etc. School funding also - NCLB/teaching to the test, forced psyc drugs, etc. The feds actually pay a $400 bounty for every kid a school district Dx's as having ADHD and put on SSRI's. Then they are suprised there are school shootings... :rolleyes:

I was lucky when I was a teen. Had a friend in my circle that was sporting a full beard at 15! - the guy NEVER got carded! Also knew a couple of kids that made moonshine... :D

Most teens just snag a whole bottle of the HARD STUFF out of their parents liquor cabinet or take a little bit out of each bottle mixing it up into a concoction called "jungle juice". It's so AWESOME! Teens getting totally fucked up on vodka and rum instead of buzzed on beer - ain't 'MeriKa great? :rolleyes:

-t
 
Last edited:
I used to have to ask people to buy my booze. Wasn't ever a pig though. I just moved to a new state and didn't know anyone. God bless the people who did me the favor.

Someone asked me about a week ago and I refused. I don't have the time nor money to get caught up in government sponsored money making schemes.

Not that I'd ever show up to court anyways. Fuck em all the way round.
 
Depends on the state. I know for sure in at least 2 states, but I think most, that you can sell beer to 18+ if it's 3.2% but only from grocery stores and convenience stores. and it's like 6% for beer from a liquor store. Thing is, one is ETOH content by weight and the other by volume, so the alcohol % is actually almost identical. It's just BS regulations/laws.

Looks like mid-late 80's for most of the country:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._history_of_alcohol_minimum_purchase_age_by_state

"Kept at 18
despite 10% highway funding
penalty under Drinking Age Act."

I Think it's TX that told the feds to go fuck themselves and raised their highway speed limit. Odd that they didn't buck everything else under fed highway funds at the same time.

National Minimum Drinking Age Act:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Minimum_Drinking_Age_Act_of_1984

This is what happens when you let the federal gvmt collect taxes, much of which is wasted "administering the program" and giving a little bit of it back to the states. WITH STRINGS ATTACHED! Now that the fud guv is shorting states, this could start breaking down. Highway funding is commonly used - hwy speed limit, seetbelt and helmet laws, etc. School funding also - NCLB/teaching to the test, forced psyc drugs, etc.

I was lucky when I was a teen. Had a friend in my circle that was sporting a full beard at 15! - the guy NEVER got carded! Also knew a couple of kids that made moonshine... :D

-t


Yeah I was part of this B.S. in the '80's. In N.C. the way the law worked out I was legal 9 months of the year but not legal for three. Luckily once they knew me at the bars they never carded again but couldn't buy somewhere I wasn't known.
As an aside I once got someone to buy me beer while in my Boy Scout uniform and underage. :p Guess we operated a bit different then "Police Explorers."
 
Last edited:
Depends on the state. I know for sure in at least 2 states, but I think most, that you can sell beer to 18+ if it's 3.2% but only from grocery stores and convenience stores. and it's like 6% for beer from a liquor store. Thing is, one is ETOH content by weight and the other by volume, so the alcohol % is actually almost identical. It's just BS regulations/laws.

OK - no more, looks like only 3-4 states or territories where that is the case now.

Looks like mid-late 80's for most of the country:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._history_of_alcohol_minimum_purchase_age_by_state

"Kept at 18
despite 10% highway funding
penalty under Drinking Age Act."

I Think it's TX that told the feds to go fuck themselves and raised their highway speed limit. Odd that they didn't buck everything else under fed highway funds blackmail at the same time.

National Minimum Drinking Age Act:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Minimum_Drinking_Age_Act_of_1984

This is what happens when you let the federal gvmt collect taxes, much of which is wasted "administering the program" and giving a little bit of it back to the states. WITH STRINGS ATTACHED! Now that the fud guv is shorting states, this could start breaking down. Highway funding is commonly used - hwy speed limit, seat belt and helmet laws, etc. School funding also - NCLB/teaching to the test, forced psyc drugs, etc. The feds actually pay a $400 bounty for every kid a school district Dx's as having ADHD and put on SSRI's. Then they are suprised there are school shootings... :rolleyes:

I was lucky when I was a teen. Had a friend in my circle that was sporting a full beard at 15! - the guy NEVER got carded! Also knew a couple of kids that made moonshine... :D

Most teens just snag a whole bottle of the HARD STUFF out of their parents liquor cabinet or take a little bit out of each bottle mixing it up into a concoction called "jungle juice". It's so AWESOME! Teens getting totally fucked up on vodka and rum instead of buzzed on beer - ain't 'MeriKa great? :roleyes:

-t
Interesting. My dad use to tell me about the days of 3.2 beer. They actually changed the law and he wasn't allowed to drink anymore. (when he was 19 IIRC) Lol.. now that would have annoyed me.

His philosophy was that if I could take a bullet in the brain for unjust causes and bankster whims I could drink a beer with the old man.
 
It isn't entrapment unless they beg or offer money.

As much as I hate things like this, you are correct that it isn't entrapment unless you convince them to commit a crime they wouldn't otherwise commit. Key word convince, because people all to often mistake sting (getting them to commit a crime that they would otherwise commit) with entrapment. It's not unlike that show where they leave keys in cars to catch car thieves. It's clear they would have stolen cars otherwise, since they're doing so here.

Though legality aside, it is certainly a grey-area at best if that person actually would have bought beer for minors had it been in a different circumstance. Maybe you caught them at the one time and person they might actually consider it for. That's where morally I find things like this very shady, as much as it is justified legally.

Anyways, no real surprise that our drinking laws only make criminals out of decent people, and that's even more saddening.
 
It isn't entrapment unless they beg or offer money. But they are targeting the wrong people. They should go after the store owners.

I actually participated in a program similar to this when I was 17. We only targeted establishments. There were very strict rules as well. As I stated before, you couldn't beg or offer money. If they asked you how old you are, your birth date, or for your drivers license you did have to provide them with accurate information. About 75% of the stores I busted actually asked for my ID but still sold it anyway. Twice was I offered by someone, that was in the store, to buy the alcohol for me when my ID was turned down, outside. I gave both of them like three opportunities not to do it but they insisted.

The only reason our state participates in programs like this is to continue to receive federal funding. At least that is what the agents told me.

Well drinking laws are bullshit so they shouldn't be targeting anybody.
 
Budweiser is said to meet the refined tastes of today’s party-time teen.

Hah. I wish Budweiser was the common place party beer. Unfortunately the majority of parties I attend are supplied with extra-poverty beers like Natural Light or Hamms. Makes Budweiser taste like heaven in comparison, which is saying something.
 
Never took much of a liking to Bud. The cheepies taste better - least round here. Other than that, I like the "high brow" stuff... some domestic l augers or foreign beers - like Irish and German... also some micro-brews..

-t
 
Hah. I wish Budweiser was the common place party beer. Unfortunately the majority of parties I attend are supplied with extra-poverty beers like Natural Light or Hamms. Makes Budweiser taste like heaven in comparison, which is saying something.

Coors was the beer of choice up at the college in the mid-80s. They were just breaking into the east coast market and were priced lower than most others.
 
Hah yeah I used to get strangers to buy me alcohol. I'd never do that favor for anyone though.
 
Back
Top