Any opinions on Neutering/Spaying dogs?

[phill4paul]

change the word euthanized to starved dead, and the same is true for humans. But I don't see anybody discouraging reproduction just because there's plenty of orphans, homeless and otherwise needy children who need parents.

I was asked my opinion on whether dogs should be spayed/neutered. That was my answer and reason for it. As for humans I think that individuals should be responsible WRT reproduction.

 

[Tpoints]

I was asked my opinion on whether dogs should be spayed/neutered. That was my answer and reason for it. As for humans I think that individuals should be responsible WRT reproduction.

what's WRT?

 

[brushfire]

 

[Tpoints]

Are you saying that in America there are a bunch of parentless kids who have not yet been adopted?

yes. are you saying there are none?

One, by-in-large the number of children available for adoption in our country is far less than the number of parents who want to adopt. That is one of the reasons why so many are looking outside our country.

So there's actually a shortage of adoptable children? Is it possible people are looking overseas because it's good PR or they think certain countries have children closer to their preferences?

Two, abandoned kids are not left to fend for themselves on the streets, like abandoned domesticated animals are.

And...?

What's that supposed to mean? You made a claim and I pointed out that you were wrong.

Yes, you corrected me and I appreciate it. I meant to say, we don't hear that "don't have children" message in the US, we only hear it from countries we condemn.

 

[phill4paul]

what's WRT?

With Regard To.

 

[Tpoints]

With Regard To.

what do we do to people who aren't responsible?

 

[tfurrh]

In Soviet Russia, dogs neuter you!

 

[phill4paul]

what do we do to people who aren't responsible?

Educate.

 

[Tpoints]

Educate.

in what way? let's just assume people will listen to whatever you tell them to do,what would you tell them to do?

 

[phill4paul]

in what way? let's just assume people will listen to whatever you tell them to do,what would you tell them to do?

On the issue of spaying and neutering dogs? Spay and neuter your pets unless you intend to take care of their offspring.

On the issue of human reproduction? Do not have children unless you intend to take care of your offspring.

Lead by example.

 

[angelatc]

yes. are you saying there are none?



So there's actually a shortage of adoptable children? Is it possible people are looking overseas because it's good PR or they think certain countries have children closer to their preferences?

Yes. What LE said is true. There are more people looking for children to adopt than there are children available. "...children closer to their preferences" only clarifies the word adoptable. Children who are disabled and/or older tend to stay in the system too long.

 

[ctiger2]

I'm of the opinion that the people who do spay/neuter their pets shouldn't OR don't really need to, and the ones who don't, should. If you're committed enough to fix your pet then you're probably responsible enough that you won't have illegitimate offspring. When I picked up my last dog I spoke to the breeder about this and she told me they don't fix any of their animals and they are very healthy. Removing a sexual organ screws up hormones. My first dog boxer I did everything you were supposed to do vaccines, neuter, etc. etc. He came down with lymphoma 4mo after vaccination and died before he turned 8. Now, I will only get the initial puppy vaccinations, no more spay/neuter. I also changed their diet to BARF and they lost bodyfat and are much healthier happier.

 

[Confederate]

Unless you're a breeder there really is no reason not to do it.

We didn't neuter my dog until he was 3 or 4. He was becoming quite aggressive and very sexual (towards other dogs, people and furniture). Once he was neutered the aggression was basically gone and he only occasionally humped my leg. He still hated Asian people for some reason, though.

 

[amy31416]

Haven't read the whole thread, but I always get female pets "fixed."

I don't like dealing with my own menstruation, much less an animal's. I have nice rugs in this house.

Never had a male cat, but I've heard that they are more likely to "spray" to mark their territory. No thanks.

If you want your male dog to remain intact, fine by me. Like most libertarians, I wouldn't give a rat's ass until your dog comes on my property and tries to hump various things.

 

[Confederate]

I don't like dealing with my own menstruation, much less an animal's. I have nice rugs in this house.

That never even crossed my mind...

Bah, gross.

 

[LibertyEagle]

I have always had male cats. I wait as long as feasible to get them neutered, so that all their organs can mature normally. But, around 6 months, or sooner if they start spraying, I get them neutered. My cats are indoor, so there is no chance they are going to impregnate a female in the interim.

 

[angelatc]

I'm of the opinion that the people who do spay/neuter their pets shouldn't OR don't really need to, and the ones who don't, should. If you're committed enough to fix your pet then you're probably responsible enough that you won't have illegitimate offspring. When I picked up my last dog I spoke to the breeder about this and she told me they don't fix any of their animals and they are very healthy. Removing a sexual organ screws up hormones. My first dog boxer I did everything you were supposed to do vaccines, neuter, etc. etc. He came down with lymphoma 4mo after vaccination and died before he turned 8. Now, I will only get the initial puppy vaccinations, no more spay/neuter. I also changed their diet to BARF and they lost bodyfat and are much healthier happier.

The problem you cited - early onset cancer - is a common genetic trait in some purebreds. It is virtually unknown in mixed breeds. http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704342604575222062208235690.html

 

[amy31416]

That never even crossed my mind...

Bah, gross.

Yes it is. My parents let my first dog go through one heat before having her spayed, and not only did every male dog stalk her, but she looked ridiculous in diapers.

 

[tod evans]

Well, the thread was about a dog, so I commented about DOGS. But, yes, the same would be true with cats.



Sure. As long as they are responsible for their decisions and actions.

With liberty, comes responsibility.

I agree with you insofar as "With liberty, comes responsibility"...

Not knowing the OP or his environment or even the dog of which he speaks, it's not possible for me to advise him one way or another..

Folks who own female dogs need to either be sure they have the means to cope with puppies or they should consider spaying, a male dog in my opinion is another matter, I believe it's up to the owner to decide if they want to deal with a mindless cur during heat season, but I don't consider them irresponsible if they choose not to neuter.

Well trained dogs are a lot like good fences.........Both make for good neighbors.

 

[angelatc]

Yes it is. My parents let my first dog go through one heat before having her spayed, and not only did every male dog stalk her, but she looked ridiculous in diapers.

I got a kitten from a litter once. Female, figured since she was going to be an indoor cat I could skip the expense of having her spayed. I went through one heat with her. The mess wasn't a factor, but the yowling and the constant need for attention.....I couldn't wait to get her fixed after that.