All of your Maine Questions answered in one thread

[devil21]

That's not true. There may be a rule that says he has to win 5 states in an unbrokered convention. But in a brokered convention anybody can win, even someone who never entered the race at all.

http://www.gop.com/About/Rules31-41.htm

No mention of brokered or otherwise anywhere in the GOP rules. Im curious to read where it's displayed how the brokered convention even works.

(b) Each candidate for nomination for President of the United States and Vice President of the United States shall demonstrate the support of a majority of the delegates from each of five (5) or more states, severally, prior to the presentation of the name of that candidate for nomination.

 

[hueylong]

40(b) has nothing to do with brokered / unbrokered convention.

It is a rule. Period.

You must win the majority of delegates in 5 contests to have your name placed in nomination at the convention.

There is no "brokered convention" in the rules. All that means is that no one goes to the convention with enough delegates to win the nomination, and they have to make a deal with someone else to throw their delegates in. Such deal-making is called "brokering", hence the term "brokered convention".

By the way -- I own brokeredconvention.com. May have to do something with it soon.

 

[bdmarti]

The way I read it:

let's say Paul failed to have the bound support of the majority of candidates from 5 states and that no nominee manages a majority of total delegates.
When the delegates become unbound, if they support Paul, their new job is to make sure no one gets a majority and petition the chair to submit a new nominee, using the majority support of the now unbound delegates.

I could be wrong though...

(b) Each candidate for nomination for President of the United States and Vice President of the United States shall demonstrate the support of a majority of the delegates from each of five (5) or more states, severally, prior to the presentation of the name of that candidate for nomination....

(d) When at the close of a roll call any candidate for nomination for President of the United States or Vice President of the United States has received a majority of the votes entitled to be cast in the convention, the chairman of the convention shall declare that the candidate has been nominated.

(e) If no candidate shall have received such majority, the chairman of the convention shall direct the roll of the states be called again and shall repeat the calling of the roll until a candidate shall have received a majority of the votes entitled to be cast in the convention.

(f) For the 2004 Republican National Convention, notwithstanding any other provision of these rules or any Rule of the House of Representatives, it shall be in the discretion of the Chair to suspend the roll call conducted to nominate the candidate for President of the United States at any time in order to conduct other Convention business under the established order of business.

 

[hueylong]

Well, here's the deal. What you are saying is theoretically correct.

But here's the problem. Even though some of these delegates could become unbound -- it is almost virtually certain that they are already pledged to someone (McCain or Romney).

They likelihood that the majorities of delegates from 5 states would shift from one of the delegate leaders to Dr. Paul -- (if he didn't go to the convention with at least enough states to have his name placed in nomination already) is 1 in a trillion.

 

[Sarge]

Maine,

Thank you for the hard work. You are making my morning. Make us all proud today.

I hope we also hear some good news from Hawaii tomorrow. They will have all but two completed today. With the time lag it might be Sunday night or Monday before we hear from them.

Good Luck today! Bring one home for Dr. Paul.

 

[malkusm]

"Density is 11.1 persons per square mile"

Sounds like my kind of place

 

[RonRules]

.

But here's the problem. Even though some of these delegates could become unbound -- it is almost virtually certain that they are already pledged to someone (McCain or Romney).

Huckabee is out of cash (pretty much) and the MSM put him on IGNORE. He will probably have to drop out after SuperTuesday.

Most GOP delegates are conservatives and there will not be much support for McCain once all the dirt is out on him. (An Coulter seriously stated that she would actually CAMPAIGN for Hillary if McCain was chosen. It's that bad.)

These same conservatives are NOT Mormon and likewise will most likely not support Romney very strongly.

That leaves Ron Paul in good shape, provided there is steady donations of at least 5 mil per month. (Note Barack raised 35 mil in Jan !!!)

It ain't over folks, but we MUST concentrate our efforts on convincing people that are not yet on our side. i.e. Older Republicans and women.

We MUST also totally schmooze these delegates to turn them to our side. One delegate is worth approximately 44,000 votes.

If you know ANY of them, put on all your charm, offer to babysit, bake cookies, they are gems!

I'm starting to hate this process. SuperTuesday should be for the ENTIRE country at once, preventing rich guys to get an early lead. Donations to the campaign should be limited to $2300 INCLUDING the rich guy that's running and corporations.

 

[Apauled]

anyone have anymore info on the results of your particular caucus to report as you did yesterday?

Thankyou

 

[subdefective]

The caucuses are going to take hours. We won't have results for a while. The Penobscot county caucus doesn't even start for two hours yet. Be patient everyone.

 

[armstrong]

what happens with the delegates that canidates won in states that have held there primaries and cacusees then dropped out of the race?

 

[tamor]

CG Mike, thanks so much for keeping us informed.

 

[UK4Paul]

Yes, thank you CG Mike and all others involved in Maine for your hard work.

 

[BarryDonegan]

this is a trend as to what happens when ron paul competes financially and others dont. he places high. this is key, as it becomes a romney vs. paul contest in the uninteresting states(most of them)

 

[ARealConservative]

A little bit of info on "The County"

# Aroostook County Population: 73,938 - US Census Bureau Data 2000
# Population is 5.8% of the state's total population
# Originally part of Washington and Penobscot Counties
# Aroostook is named for an Indian word meaning "beautiful river"
# Incorporated March 16, 1839
# Contains 2 cities, 54 towns, 11 plantations, and 108 unorganized townships
# Density is 11.1 persons per square mile
# Area - 6,672 square miles (21.6% of the state's area): 89% of the County's area is forest, 1% lakes, ponds and rivers, 10% cultivated farmland
# Houlton is the Aroostook County seat with offices in Caribou and Fort Kent
# Maine's northernmost county bordered to the east, west and north by Canada
# Aroostook County is larger than Connecticut and Rhode Island combined
# Aroostook County is the largest U.S. county east of the Mississippi River.
# Major crops: broccoli, potatoes, hay, small grain rotation crops
# Site of two transatlantic balloon crossing launch sites
# Aroostook County is home to the Allagash Wilderness Waterway

I've been there - Loring Air Force Base specifically.

 

[Misesian]

That's not true. There may be a rule that says he has to win 5 states in an unbrokered convention. But in a brokered convention anybody can win, even someone who never entered the race at all.

Yeah, this was my understanding always until people here said the 5 state rule in brokered. I'm pretty sure that's not the case because there's talks about candidates who aren't even RUNNING picking up the nod in a brokered convention.

 

[Jwaksman]

Yeah, this was my understanding always until people here said the 5 state rule in brokered. I'm pretty sure that's not the case because there's talks about candidates who aren't even RUNNING picking up the nod in a brokered convention.

Yeah, I've heard people talking about everyone getting fed up at the convention and just voting in Fred Thompson to bring back a more pure conservative than either Romney or McCain. I believe this is what happened with Warren G Harding in 1920, where he wasn't a top competitor but due to some back-room dealings became a top competitor on the 7th or 8th ballot.


I don't know if the rules have changed, though. But we all know this - the rules are intentionally complex in order to make sure that the party insiders have their way. This is what I tell people as I work towards getting us a delegate out of Dane County, Wisconsin. We need to out-insider the insiders.

 

[armstrong]

so Huck wins iowa and drops out , are his delagates ?free to support any one still running for nominee?

 

[Crickett]

Well, I have a question. Since you are reporting some delegates, I would assume that these caususing places ARE over now, right? I mean..no one can come in and snatch more delegates, right? If so, then great. If not, and they aren't going to be over until Monday I still feel insecure about giving out info. Those Romney people are merciless...