I'm the OP who originally requested the 10- and 15-second ads.
Here's what I said in my other thread:
"My ideal 10- or 15-sec spot (which probably doesn't exist!) would have the short slogan suggested by some here on RPF: (I don't know what the background would be, maybe footage of Dr. Paul.) The narration would just say: "End the war. Vote for Ron Paul. Stop our economic crisis. Vote for Ron Paul. Restore America. Vote for Ron Paul." (A 15-second spot would probably have time for one more phrase in there, e.g. "Restore our individual freedoms. Vote for Ron Paul." I would place that phrase 3rd in this list.)
I would think that if people heard this message repeated enough, they would have a very good idea of Dr. Paul's basic platform, and this might be an effective way to spread the message."
So, I do appreciate your work, coffeewithchess, but I have to agree with those who say that the picture is too cartoonish, and the message doesn't convey any useful info.
Instead, like I suggested above, I would
a) use at least one, and maybe more, "presidential"-looking photos of Dr. Paul (e.g. see the thread "What's your favorite Ron Paul picture?":
http://www.ronpaulforums.com/showthread.php?t=38574&highlight=favorite ) or, even better, some video footage of Dr. Paul.
and b) use a few short but *informative* phrases, as above. We want to *inform* people about Dr. Paul's positions in a short amount of time.