Supreme Court Rules Large Swath of Oklahoma Is Indian Reservation

idiom

Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2007
Messages
8,598
I hope libertarians get on the right side of this.

If America is to be a nation of laws, property rights, and contracts then this has to extend to natives, and the treaties must be upheld.

I don't care if it creates turmoil. Ending the FED would create turmoil too.

How many people here think taxation is theft but expropriating land isn't?

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/09/us/supreme-court-oklahoma-mcgirt-creek-nation.html
 
sure!

now who do i pay tribute to so im not murdered in my sleep?

Ideally it would be a new state under Creek nation. Such a clean solution is unlikely to be built though. Also most of your tribute still goes to the Feds.

New Zealand has been going through this process since 1975 when our Supreme court upheld the Treaty of Waitangi. Its been an okay process for the most part. Who knew laws and markets could process turmoil so easily without a central plan outlining how each person will be safe in their beds?
 
So instead of traveling far and buying federal tax free smokes up in NY for $12/carton, I can go elsewhere?
 
Federal jurisdiction grab so they can hand the land over to drilling corporations without state government interference.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-...ze-oil-rich-indian-reservations-idUSKBN13U1B1

Now, a group of advisors to President-elect Donald Trump on Native American issues wants to free those resources from what they call a suffocating federal bureaucracy that holds title to 56 million acres of tribal lands, two chairmen of the coalition told Reuters in exclusive interviews.

The group proposes to put those lands into private ownership - a politically explosive idea that could upend more than century of policy designed to preserve Indian tribes on U.S.-owned reservations, which are governed by tribal leaders as sovereign nations.


Well, I guess [MENTION=65299]Swordsmyth[/MENTION] was right about a few of the things that Trump promised during the campaign actually being fulfilled. Oil billionaires gaining control of more resources. Since we'll all be driving around in electric automated Teslas soon enough, that oil will head to other parts of the world and be used for Indian and Chinese development. Need big pipelines and global trade agreements like USMCA to pull that off. Is the picture of where this is heading becoming clear enough for most yet? Americans shoe-horned into highly controlled mega cities while the remainder of the land mass is used to aid the development of the rest of world. Enjoy the Teslas and plant burgers, folks.
 
Last edited:
Federal jurisdiction grab so they can hand the land over to drilling corporations without state government interference.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-...ze-oil-rich-indian-reservations-idUSKBN13U1B1




Well, I guess @Swordsmyth was right about a few of the things that Trump promised during the campaign actually being fulfilled. Oil billionaires gaining control of more resources. Since we'll all be driving around in electric automated Teslas soon enough, that oil will head to other parts of the world and be used for Indian and Chinese development. Need big pipelines and global trade agreements like USMCA to pull that off. Is the picture of where this is heading becoming clear enough for most yet?
The commie wants government to lock up all the land and keep the market from utilizing resources.


Got it.
 
Federal jurisdiction grab so they can hand the land over to drilling corporations without state government interference.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-...ze-oil-rich-indian-reservations-idUSKBN13U1B1




Well, I guess [MENTION=65299]Swordsmyth[/MENTION] was right about a few of the things that Trump promised during the campaign actually being fulfilled. Oil billionaires gaining control of more resources. Since we'll all be driving around in electric automated Teslas soon enough, that oil will head to other parts of the world and be used for Indian and Chinese development. Need big pipelines and global trade agreements like USMCA to pull that off. Is the picture of where this is heading becoming clear enough for most yet? Americans shoe-horned into highly controlled mega cities while the remainder of the land mass is used to aid the development of the rest of world. Enjoy the Teslas and plant burgers, folks.

That makes better sense now. Thanks.
 
The commie wants government to lock up all the land and keep the market from utilizing resources.


Got it.

Yes, yes "the market" demands American oil be sent to China. Not globalists and billionaire campaign donors. "The market".
 
The commie wants government to lock up all the land and keep the market from utilizing resources.


Got it.


You get to call me out for wanting to buy smokes cheap; my smokes don't Fund your Fed.
 
Yes, yes "the market" demands American oil be sent to China. Not globalists and billionaire campaign donors. "The market".
Yes, we know that you want government to control where resources go and you are spouting commie rhetoric to support it.

Please keep it up so everyone is left without doubt who you really are.
 
Before any "so much winning' memes get posted here, it's so important to continue to support stable genius DJT (R) type strong leaders so courts can be packed with the right kind of conservatives.
 
Last edited:
Yes, we know that you want government to control where resources go and you are spouting commie rhetoric to support it.

Please keep it up so everyone is left without doubt who you really are.

Your post doesn't make any sense. You're flailing. This -is- the federal government taking control of where state and local resources go. I don't mind if a STATE government has a say in where the state's resources go. That's the 10th Amendment.
 
Last edited:
And another commie "anarchist" reveals that he wants government to control resources and keep them off the market.

You are a hoot tonight ;-) Why haven't you responded to my question in the other thread? Too difficult? Not in the playbook? Just plain stuck? Confused that the NY Lib would do such things (plural)?
 
Your post doesn't make any sense. You're flailing. This -is- the federal government taking control of where state and local resources go. I don't mind if a STATE government has a say in where the state's resources go. That's the 10th Amendment.
You are the one supporting government controlling resources and opposing the free market.
It doesn't matter what level of government controls the resources, it's still communism and you are supporting it.
 
"Indian reservation?" Not "sovereign Indian land?"

Well, that's mighty white of 'em ...

That's the legalese in action. An "indian reservation" is whatever Congress and/or SCOTUS decides it is, based on whatever definition they choose to enshrine into legislation/decision. And of course, the word "sovereign" is a bad, bad word! Can't have that word plastered across mass media articles, can we???


This SCOTUS decision is likely also the real reason that Trump was in Tulsa recently. Campaign rallies and photo op visits around the country are always cover for "business" like this. Rallies and the like are window dressing to distract from "business" that takes place behind closed doors before, during and after the public photo ops. Presidents never fly/travel anywhere simply to appear in public.
 
Last edited:
"Indian reservation?" Not "sovereign Indian land?"

Well, that's mighty white of 'em ...


That's the legalese in action. An "indian reservation" is whatever Congress and/or SCOTUS decides it is, based on whatever definition they choose to enshrine into legislation/decision.


This SCOTUS decision is likely also the real reason that Trump was in Tulsa recently. Campaign rallies and photo op visits around the country are always cover for "business" like this. Rallies and the like are window dressing to distract from "business" that takes place behind closed doors before, during and after the public photo ops. Presidents never fly/travel anywhere simply to appear in public.

This is where Swordy bails out of the thread.
 
Back
Top