Well, you are comparing paper silver to physical silver. There has been a disconnect for quite some time now. There will always be more paper silver than physical. Well, at least till the scam is revealed.
Question: Am I only allowed to short the futures market if I have the physical gold/silver/wheat/oil in my actual possession? If the answer to that question is "Of course not" then you'll always have more paper than physical. That's the whole fucking point. That's how the system is supposed to work, and it's completely legitimate. How do you think ranchers work? When they have to contract an entire year's supply of soybean meal? They buy product that doesn't exist yet. The crush facility that produces the meal promises it'll be there for pickup at each of the contract dates. The crush facility then buys soybean meal contracts for each month of the meal they contracted to sell to the rancher in order to hedge against volatile prices. The rancher sells soybean meal contracts to hedge their bet as well. This all happens in advance when no product yet exists. Is this a scam? Or is this just how the market has worked for hundreds of years? There's a reason why you can go to the store and buy steak or go to KFC and they'll have chicken, or why there's milk for your cereal, or why there's gas at a gas station to fill your car up with. Because if there was no futures market, we wouldn't have any of these commodities available at affordable prices and there would be countless producers and refiners going bankrupt year after year because they bought a bushel of beans at $14/bushel, only to have their purchase plunge to $10/bushel forcing them to lose $4/bushel because the futures market wasn't there to have them lock in their $14/bushel purchase. And you can't have a liquid or efficient futures market without having more paper than physical. Sorry, but it's a far cry from fractional reserve banking, my friend, if that's what you think it equates to.
See, comments like these drive me up the wall. When people who don't understand the purpose of futures and their role as a risk management tool for the overall market.
There's always more paper everything than physical. That's how the commodities world works...agriculture, metals, energy, that's the entire point of the paper market. It's there to be a hedge device for producers and holders of commodities. If you had to wait until you refined every ounce of silver or grew every bushel of wheat, there wouldn't be much of a fuckin' futures market, nor a purpose for it. THAT'S WHY IT'S CALLED "FUTURES". You contract INTO the future in anticipation of what you have. It's completely legitimate. What happens if you don't have those bushels and someone seeks to take delivery and you haven't closed out of your position? Same thing happens anytime you make a contract on the market and can't deliver. No different from someone writing a contract to have a construction company build a new house. If they don't do it, they better remedy the situation. Same thing with futures.
The vast majority of contracts never go to delivery, and why would they? The futures market is there to make sure prices for producers, refiners, and consumers are locked in so they aren't open ended in case the market moves against them. I mean if you think the entire fucking futures industry is a scam, then you need to step away from the David Morgan BS and actually work with futures to understand how they work.
How do you expect farmers to hedge new crop one year out if the bushels of wheat aren't grown yet? According to you, that's part of the "scam" that needs to be revealed.
I suppose the tens of thousands of farmers across the nation are conspiring as well. Probably not, but having a wet dream that there's JP Morgan and other executives in a dark room "manipulating" silver specifically is pretty entertaining.
And there hasn't been that big of a disconnect between buying physical silver and the futures market whatsoever. I can still buy 100 oz. silver bars for less than $1.70/oz over spot. Not bad when you figure in profit margins for the dealer to buy from the refiner and to sell to someone like myself.