Karl Rove and that anti-Huntsman "Manchurian Candidate" advert

Joined
Dec 29, 2011
Messages
19
I won't pollute the boards by linking them, but RedState and some other neo-con warfarist sites have been highlighting a (supposedly RP-fan created) video casting Huntsman as a "Manchurian candidate" for adopting Chinese kids, speaking Chinese, etc. etc. This, of course, proves that RP is a racist, his supporters are racists, and that not wanting to bomb foreigners is racist.

People have already asked some important questions, such as:

1. Why are sites like RedState highlighting an obscure YouTube video which was not created by RP's campaign, any of the superPACs supporting him, or anyone of any note at all (the YT user's real name is unknown, and he/she has posted no other videos)?

2. Who brought it to these sites' attention?

3. Why would a genuine RP fan bother going after a fringe candidate like Huntsman, whose quixotic campaign shows few signs of coming to life and whose tiny pool of vocal supporters hardly constitute a threat to RP or any of the other frontrunners in the primaries?


I think those considerations make it clear that RP doesn't benefit from this behavior. So who does? Well, people might find it instructive to read this piece, written in 2004, on Karl Rove's election tactics. The most important part:

How Rove has conducted himself while winning campaigns is a subject of no small controversy in political circles. It is frequently said of him, in hushed tones when political folks are doing the talking, that he leaves a trail of damage in his wake—a reference to the substantial number of people who have been hurt, politically and personally, through their encounters with him. Rove's reputation for winning is eclipsed only by his reputation for ruthlessness, and examples abound of his apparent willingness to cross moral and ethical lines.

In the opening pages of Bush's Brain, Wayne Slater describes an encounter with Rove while covering the 2000 campaign for the Dallas Morning News. Slater had written an article for that day's paper detailing Rove's history of dirty tricks, including a 1973 conference he had organized for young Republicans on how to orchestrate them. Rove was furious. "You're trying to ruin me!" Slater recalls him shouting. The anecdote points up one of the paradoxes of Rove's career. Articles like Slater's are surprisingly few, yet as I interviewed people who knew Rove, they brought up examples of unscrupulous tactics—some of them breathtaking—as a matter of course.

A typical instance occurred in the hard-fought 1996 race for a seat on the Alabama Supreme Court between Rove's client, Harold See, then a University of Alabama law professor, and the Democratic incumbent, Kenneth Ingram. According to someone who worked for him, Rove, dissatisfied with the campaign's progress, had flyers printed up—absent any trace of who was behind them—viciously attacking See and his family. "We were trying to craft a message to reach some of the blue-collar, lower-middle-class people," the staffer says. "You'd roll it up, put a rubber band around it, and paperboy it at houses late at night. I was told, 'Do not hand it to anybody, do not tell anybody who you're with, and if you can, borrow a car that doesn't have your tags.' So I borrowed a buddy's car [and drove] down the middle of the street … I had Hefty bags stuffed full of these rolled-up pamphlets, and I'd cruise the designated neighborhoods, throwing these things out with both hands and literally driving with my knees." The ploy left Rove's opponent at a loss. Ingram's staff realized that it would be fruitless to try to persuade the public that the See campaign was attacking its own candidate in order "to create a backlash against the Democrat," as Joe Perkins, who worked for Ingram, put it to me. Presumably the public would believe that Democrats were spreading terrible rumors about See and his family. "They just beat you down to your knees," Ingram said of being on the receiving end of Rove's attacks. See won the race.

Fortunately, it seems that even if Hunt or those close to him are morally compromised enough to be willing to resort to such tactics, the competence which characterized Rove's operations is lacking. Nonetheless, I think it important to be aware how these things work, and to think about how they can be countered effectively.
 
RedState are a bunch of delusional fascists. Try spending any time posting there. It's miserable, the main bloggers treat it like their little fiefdom, and the discussion is incredibly limited to a few acceptable positions.

Just because these people have a megaphone, doesn't mean that anyone is listening to them. Not anyone that matters anyway.
 
It's all over Google news along with Billboard saying that Kelly Clarkson didn't have a Ron Paul bump.
 
So if I go post a Mitt Romney video that is completely stupid but calls is hateful towards Rick Santorum on an issue of race... it will undoubtedly prove that Mitt Romney supporters are racist...right?
 
Last edited:
So if I go post a Mitt Romney video that is completely stupid but calls Rick Santorum a racist... it will undoubtedly prove that Mitt Romney supporters are racist...right?
No, they'll just say it's probably one of those Ron Paul supporters.
 
Huntsman is using disgusting campaign tactics. I hope Rand absolutely ruins him in 2016.
 
This video is going viral all of the internet. It already has 30K views. The Paul campaign should make a facebook post and denounce the Huntsman campaign's dirty Rovian politics. This could backfire hard on the Huntsman camp if the Paul camp would address it.
 
No, they'll just say it's probably one of those Ron Paul supporters.
So it's always lose-lose for us Ron Paul supporters...? But always win-win for every other candidates supporters. Got it. We are horrible human beings who can right by no one... and every other candidates supporters are perfect church going angels. The media should really try to keep pissing us off :)
 
Last edited:
I just watched this ad. It is so obvious it was not done by a Ron Paul supporter. It's just not the way we think.

Sure, many of us do and say some really stupid things, but this isn't one of them. Oh, how I hope someone can prove what happened here!
 
I'm so infuriated by this stupid video and not convinced that it's from an actual RP supporter. Have we figured out who made/posted it? They need to be publically called out.

I'm also angry that someone in the RP campaign thought it was a good idea to taunt Huntsman on twitter.
 
What in the world are they going to do over at Redstate when the race clearly becomes RP v. Romney?

I bet they then get behind Romney and show themselves to be the hypocrites they are.
 
Huntsman is as dirty as they get. The Huntsman campaign or someone who supports him created this vid. So obvious.
 
RedState are a bunch of delusional fascists. Try spending any time posting there. It's miserable, the main bloggers treat it like their little fiefdom, and the discussion is incredibly limited to a few acceptable positions.

Just because these people have a megaphone, doesn't mean that anyone is listening to them. Not anyone that matters anyway.
The creator specifically tweeted out this video to Erick Erickson / Red State, as well as to other neocon journalists hostile to us and put some conspiracy theorist accounts in for good measure (@JFKTruther, @InfoTerrorism).

Really, why would you tweet out a video like that to ERICK ERICKSON, possibly the very most biased pundit against Paul, if you're a Paul supporter?

These tweets were designed to do maximum damage. Obvious smear job is obvious: https://twitter.com/#!/NHLiberty4Paul

NHLiberty4Paul NH Liberty 4 Paul
Why @jonhuntsman can't beat @ronpaul. Video: bit.ly/wpc4yY @mckaycoppins @chris_moody
5 Jan
NH Liberty 4 Paul
NHLiberty4Paul NH Liberty 4 Paul
Why @jonhuntsman can't beat @ronpaul. Video: bit.ly/wpc4yY @dsraussthehill @brandonkiser @nhpatch @zekejmiller @ewerickson @LOLGOP
5 Jan
NH Liberty 4 Paul
NHLiberty4Paul NH Liberty 4 Paul
Why @jonhuntsman can't beat @ronpaul. Video: bit.ly/wpc4yY @DanGainor @secupp @JFKTruther @InfoTerrorism @michellemalkin @brodigan
5 Jan
NH Liberty 4 Paul
NHLiberty4Paul NH Liberty 4 Paul
What are @jonhuntsman's true values? bit.ly/wpc4yY #fitn #gop2012 #ronpaul #campusreform #revpac #endorseliberty #jon2012girls
 
Last edited:
Back
Top