If Fracking Causes Earthquakes Who Pays the Damages?

presence

Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2011
Messages
19,330
Magnitude 5.1 Earthquake Shakes Tulsa, Oklahoma
The Weather Channel‎ - 30 mins ago

Reports of earthquake tremors and grumbles in Tulsa, Oklahoma, popped up on social ...

M5.1 - 28km NW of Fairview, Oklahoma
Earthquake Hazards Program‎ - 2 hours ago

Magnitude 5.1 earthquake recorded near Fairview, Oklahoma | Fox News
Fox News‎ - 2 hours ago


earthquakes2.png





It’s Official: Oklahoma Experiences More Earthquakes Than Anywhere Else in the World

Lorraine Chow | November 16, 2015 10:47 am

It’s official: Oklahoma now has more earthquakes than anywhere else in the world, according to a spokesman from the Oklahoma Corporation Commission (OCC), which oversees the Sooner State’s oil and gas industry.





Several earthquakes have struck Oklahoma in just these past four days. As Oklahoma Corporation Commission spokesman Matt Skinner said about the state’s increased seismic activity,

“We’ve got an earthquake issue.”

“OCC has developed areas of interest, where earthquake clusters have occurred. A cluster is two earthquakes within a half mile of each other, with one measuring at least magnitude 3.2. Originally, they were three-mile circles, then six-mile circles. The circles grew in number and now encompass a very large area of Oklahoma—about 9,000 square miles in all, [Skinner] said,” reported the Enid News.

Scientists have linked this never-ending spate of tremors to the state’s drilling boom. The Oklahoma Geological Survey concluded that the injection of wastewater byproducts into deep underground disposal wells from fracking operations has triggered the seismic activity in Oklahoma.
As EcoWatch reported two months ago, Oklahoma went from two earthquakes a year before 2009 to two a day. This year, roughly 700 earthquakes of magnitude 3 or higher has shook the state, compared to 20 in 2009.

Sierra Club threatens to sue four #Oklahoma #fracking companies for causing #earthquakes. https://t.co/wNfSVbzBGnpic.twitter.com/ME3ozbjiRv
— Tim Ream (@ourcarbon) November 4, 2015


The tremors are such a frequent occurrence that the OCC has forced changes to 500 disposal wells around the state, including the shut down of wells around the city of Cushing, which holds one of the largest crude oil storage facilities in the world.

The OCC is requiring well operators to show that water is not being injected below the state’s deepest rock formations, which is believed to contribute to the earthquakes.

Incidentally, Oklahoma has about 4,500 disposal wells with about 3,500 still in operation, so these regulations only applied to a small fraction of the wells.
Skinner said the Oklahoma Geological Survey has seen an overall reduction in earthquakes. However, he noted, “Now, this weekend may have blown that out of the water, I don’t know.”

“Again, based on the data, it would appear that even if you do the right thing, it’s going to take a long time,” he said. “There’s no quick off switch.”

@UptownBobby RT @kfor Earthquake rattle Cushing residents authorities shut down disposal wells http://t.co/zscqdThjta pic.twitter.com/D4gfuhnQeP
— Nancy Fressh (@NorthsideNancy) September 18, 2015


In August, even pro-business Oklahoma Gov. Mary Fallin admitted there was a “direct correlation between the increase of earthquakes that we’ve seen in Oklahoma [and] disposal wells.”

However, Fallin is still weighing some of the pros and cons of fracking in her state. Oklahoma is one of the top natural gas-producing states in the country, and the sector provides a significant number of jobs in the state.

“We want to do it wisely without harming the economic activity we certainly enjoy and the revenue, quite frankly, we certainly enjoy,” Fallin said. “The council has worked very hard to ensure the energy sector, state agencies, environmentalists and academia are all talking and sharing that data and we have a scientific-based approach to reducing seismicity in our state.”

Many Oklahomans are worried that, one day, a damaging earthquake could strike. Fallin’s advice to residents is that “they should call their insurance agent and see what types of products are available,” to protect themselves. This advice from the governor was unsurprisingly met by criticism.

Oklahoma is Rocking: FAIRVIEW, Okla. (AP) — The U.S. Geological Survey has recorded a 4.3 magnitude earthquake… https://t.co/eIbs7D05DT
— Change Tulsa (@CHNGTulsa) November 16, 2015



Angela Spotts, co-founder of Stop Fracking Oklahoma (formerly Stop Fracking Payne County), said many insurance policies have high deductibles and cover only catastrophic damage, according to Tulsa World.

“It really appears to me we are protecting the industry in this state,” Spotts said. “Their jobs are important. But my home and all the people I speak for that don’t have the courage to stand up and speak out, our lives, homes, property and well-being is every bit as important as the jobs in the oil and gas industry. And I sincerely don’t believe the actions have been quick enough and fast enough and protecting from one of the big ones from happening.”
 
Last edited:
I'm sure it would be the people who live in the State. Of course the profiteers aren't going to pay. The profiteers are still denying fracking and earthquakes are associated with each other.
 
In a libertarian utopia, who would pay when the liabilities of an action are not tied to a single individual, and can not be tied to a single event?
 
Back
Top