Gene Arensberg: Full-blown backwardation in silver

  • Thread starter Thread starter PeacePlan
  • Start date Start date
P

PeacePlan

Guest
Saturday, February 05, 2011

Near Zero Contango in COMEX Silver Futures

HOUSTON -- We are in the process of pouring over the data from this week, and just below is something we are going to be hearing a lot more about in the coming days and weeks. As of Friday, February 4, 2011, there was near zero contango in the COMEX silver futures market.

More in a moment, but first, here is this week’s closing table.




Note the very strong outperformance of silver to gold this week. There is likely a very good reason for it.

No Contango in Silver
Contango, where the spot price of a commodity is lower than the following futures contracts, is the normal condition in the precious metals futures markets. Contango is a sign that a commodity is in ample or adequate supply.

Backwardation means that the cash or spot price is higher than the futures price for the same commodity. Backwardation occurs when demand for immediate delivery outstrips the market’s ability to deliver the commodity. Backwardation occurs when there are too few sellers of the physical commodity to accommodate all of the actual buyers, so a near-premium develops to compensate the sellers willing to part with metal in return for taking delivery later.

When there is zero contango, it means that there is not even one futures contract that is higher than the current spot or cash price. Zero contango and structural backwardation (where each succeeding futures contract is lower for most or the entire strip) is also known as an “inverse carry” market because the futures no longer compensate holders for the cost of carry, capital, storage and insurance relative to the spot price.


We cannot overemphasize how unusual and rare it is to have zero contango in the silver futures strip. As of the close on Friday, the spot price for silver was $29.07. The closing price for the December 2015 futures contract was $29.02 or 5-cents less, repeat less, than today’s spot price – for delivery four years hence. The few futures contracts that were above the spot price were all within two cents of it. For all intents and purposes, silver is in a zero contango situation now. Just below is the closing strip from Friday, February 4, courtesy of InsideStocks.com.



That means that there is heavy demand for immediate delivery silver. It means that silver players are earning a premium to sell physical for delivery now and to wait for the return of their metal until the March contract, the near active contract, which is trading at 1.6-cents lower than spot (blue circle).

Full-blown backwardation has arrived in the COMEX silver futures market. Backwardation suggests that competition for whatever metal is available is heavy and most analysts consider silver backwardation to be a decidedly bullish condition.

By the way, as of Friday, there was only enough silver metal in the Registered category in COMEX depositories to accommodate 8,680 COMEX contracts (43.4 million ounces), or about 6.6% of the 130,601 contracts open as of Thursday’s tally. (Another 59 million ounces was listed as “Eligible” and some of that metal could conceivably be coaxed into the Registered category at some price. Some of the Eligible silver is likely already committed for other purposes and is merely stored in the COMEX system awaiting delivery.)

Evidence of tightness in the silver market continues to surface in other words.

In addition to the near zero contango in silver, we also noted some interesting developments in the commitments of traders report just released Friday. We plan to mention some of them as well as our own trading intentions in the notations in our linked graphs on the subscriber pages by tomorrow, Sunday at 18:00 ET. Vultures, (Got Gold Report subscribers) please log in and navigate to the GGR Charts section in the subscriber pages for more then.

As a reminder, for up to the minute availability for the real deal physical silver and gold, CMI Gold and Silver is our first choice. Give them a call (Toll free 800-528-1380) or stop by their excellent web site by clicking on the CMI link above and to the left.

Finally, we urge all our readers and Vultures to catch the video presentations at the just-concluded Cheviot Sound Money Conference from January 27th. The presentations have been made available at this Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee (GATA) link: http://www.gata.org/node/9564 We consider it well worth the time. Be sure to have a note pad at the ready.

That is all for now, but there is more to come.

Peaceplan: I see this as very bullish as I have been watching this since 2001 and can only recall 1 or maybe 2 other times this has occurred?

http://www.gotgoldreport.com/2011/02/near-zero-contango-in-comex-silver-futures.html

 
Last edited:
seems like some pretty substantial tremors in the silver market...maybe the correction is coming soon, maybe it isn't...
 
Saturday afternoon, this article, Near Zero Contango in Comex Silver Futures, came to my attention in which the author noted that silver was in zero contango throughout all silver contracts. I have verified that this is correct. This means that silver is in very short supply at the spot price as investors are not willing to sell their metal at spot and buy a futures contract for fear that they will not get the physical metal. This is the first time this has ever happened in silver. The bankers have tried to bid up the prices on silver at the further out months at the comex, trying to keep the facade that silver is in proper contango and ample supplies of silver are with us. This is not true as we now know that silver is in short supply as I have indicated to you on many occasions. Adrian Douglas has also presented another paper on silver today. For seven years, gold and silver have traded in perfect uniformity. If gold goes up by 1% then silver will rise somewhere around 1%. Douglas has now concluded that the shackles have been removed and silver is now on its own. Douglas also noted that silver is basically in complete backwardation or no contango.

I have highlighted both commentaries for you and this is probably the most important development in silver for the past 20 years. ...

http://harveyorgan.blogspot.com/2011/02/silver-in-complete-backwardation.html

On September 21, 2010 I published an article entitled “More Forensic Evidence of Gold & Silver Price Manipulation”. In that article I showed how silver from 2003 to 2010 had never traded freely at all; I showed that silver was algorithmically traded with gold and there was a very clear relationship between the price of gold and the price of silver. For those who haven’t read the previous article the following figure 1 (figure 4 in the previous article) demonstrates the inter-relationship.

011511Fig1.jpg_1.png

Figure 1 Cross-plot of Silver versus Gold 2003-2010

Figure 1 is a cross-plot of the price of gold against the price of silver for every trading day from June 2003 to September 2010. There are two linear relationships, one is pre-2008 (black line) and the second is post 2008 (green line). The best fit equations for the two data sets are also given on the chart.

The stunning revelation from the data analysis was that if on any day I knew what the price of gold was I would be able to calculate the silver price from the equation of the relationship! How is that possible in a free market? It simply is not possible and so the conclusion is that silver is not in a free market but is manipulated to move algorithmically with the price of gold. I have written many articles that show that gold is itself manipulated and suppressed (for example, see Gold Market is not “Fixed”, it’s Rigged)

I have updated the chart of Figure 1 which is shown in Figure 2.

011511Fig2.jpg_1.png

Figure 2 Cross-plot of Silver versus Gold 2003-2011

Since September 2010 silver has broken its golden shackles. The algorithmic trading that kept the price of silver subdued for seven years has been completely annihilated.

On Friday silver closed in complete backwardation on the Comex. Spot silver closed at $29.075/oz while FEB 2011 closed at $29.064/oz and DEC 2015 closed at $29.026/oz. I believe this is the first time in history that this has happened. Silver traded in backwardation between the spot price and futures contract up to one year out during the blatantly manipulative precious metals bashing of January, but now the entire futures structure is in backwardation. This is a sure sign there are shortages of silver because it means that buyers will pay a premium for silver delivered sooner rather than later.
...

http://marketforceanalysis.com/article/latest_article_02511.html
 
The closing price for the December 2015 futures contract was $29.02 or 5-cents less, repeat less, than today’s spot price – for delivery four years hence.

Where can you lock in silver for delivery 4 years out at this price?
 
Interesting...

...
When the spot market price of silver is higher than future months, a condition called backwardation, this is a sign of a physical supply squeeze. For the spot price of silver to be higher than almost every month of future contracts is a signal of an extreme supply shortage.

I noted a couple of weeks ago that the retail premium on US 90% Silver Coins had increased enough that it was no longer profitable for dealers to sell the coins to refiners to melt down, thus depriving refineries of this source of physical silver. In his article, Douglas noted that refineries are now declining to accept new orders because of the difficulty of obtaining physical silver to process.
...

http://news.coinupdate.com/silver-poised-to-outperform-gold-0670/

I didn't think it was legal for refiners to melt down the 90% coins as they are still legal tender.
 
Only pennies and nickels are illegal to melt. Dimes and quarters can be melted.

I see this from 1996:

http://www.usmint.gov/pressroom/index.cfm?action=press_release&ID=724

The United States Mint has implemented regulations to limit the exportation, melting, or treatment of one-cent (penny) and 5-cent (nickel) United States coins, to safeguard against a potential shortage of these coins in circulation....

Specifically, the new regulations prohibit, with certain exceptions, the melting or treatment of all one-cent and 5-cent coins...

The new regulations authorize a fine of not more than $10,000, or imprisonment of not more than five years, or both, against a person who knowingly violates the regulations. In addition, by law, any coins exported, melted, or treated in violation of the regulation shall be forfeited to the United States Government.

I do not see in the press release (or whatever it is) where the "new regulation" is referenced. In other words, doesn't congress need to make a law? Where's the bill that was passed. Have we really gotten to the point where a department of the government can impose specific fines and imprisonment by declaration!? I do see a link to the "interim rule" but the link gives an error.

I've got a $100 box of nickels...now worth about $146 in copper. I don't plan on melting but I may buy another box soon.
 
Back
Top